Sergio or Silva?

[Yates]

Nope, no, never, can't do it.

 

[IanBishopsHaircut]

I choose death.

Or cake

 

[aguero93:20]

Or cake

In the words of Thomas Henry, give me cake/Sergio+Dave or give me death.

 

[greasedupdeafguy]

Aguero easily wouldnt take any other striker in the world over him. There are players out there that can replace Silva, same cant be said for Aguero imo.

 

[NorCalBlue]

This thread is akin to being asked which testicle do you want removing. Both have given me many happy memories but it's still possible to function with just one of them.
I'd hate to chose but if I really had to, I would keep SIlva. Purely because if they both lost a yard of pace, Silva would still be capable of playing the same way and would still be a world class player. If Aguero lost a yard he would be nowhere near as effective.
It's a strange one really, because if we put them both on the transfer list today, Aguero would command a much higher fee, but he is also the one who is easier to replace. Although you wouldn't be able to find a like for like replacement for either of them.
If either of them got an offer they couldn't refuse, I wouldn't begrudge them a move. Both of them have repaid their transfer fees twice over and then some. I would be distraught at the thought of either of them leaving but I would wish them well. Unless they went to the rags of course.

Interesting points on Silva and Aguero, but you didn't answer the testicle question. My money says you keep the right one.

 

[mrbelfry]

I'd spend a month wearing the old black away kit such would be my depth of mourning if Silva left. I love Sergio but if we ever got in a friendship it would only be so I could get David's number. David is the best player I've seen at City in my lifetime. Despite Sergio being a better striker it looks like hard work for him whilst David just floats around weaving magic.

 

[Wafty Cranker]

This is like Sophie's choice for God's sake.

Damocles you sadist.

I've reported this thread!

 

[evianglass]

This is like asking would you rather lose your left leg below the knee or have to plough your own mother every night for 7 months. Why are we even doing this to ourselves?

i am actually laughing out loud... @BluePhil8, you have a sick sense of humor... and i agree why are we doing this?

 

[kippax kid]

+ 99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999.

Are you German?

 

[oakiecokie]

Are you German?

Non !!