Silva or Robinho?

[AdamManCity]

Given his work rate and attitude 90% of us would pick silva however who is the better player? I still think silva, he is so important to us in what he does and I don't think a hard working Robinho offers the creativity and passing range of silva. Goals do come into it but I think we have enough goalscorers so for me it's silva without a doubt.

 

[benCTID]

Silva.

 

[BringBackSwales]

Given his work rate and attitude 90% of us would pick silva however who is the better player? I still think silva, he is so important to us in what he does and I don't think a hard working Robinho offers the creativity and passing range of silva. Goals do come into it but I think we have enough goalscorers so for me it's silva without a doubt.

an inaccurate post as there is no such thing as "a hard working Robinho", I am sorry to say

 

[CITYROBBO]

100 % of city fans would pick silva. Robinho isn't in his league!

 

[MCFC BOB]

Silva.

 

[sboroMCFC]

Robinho

 

[MCFC BOB]

Silva.

/thread.

 

[Bluemoon115]

Silva can do everything Robinho can.

But Robinho can't do everything Silva can.

Silva 100%.

 

[Armaan]

I think a mistake lots of city fans could make here is judging Robinho solely based on his time at our club.... Thats unfair because the players he played with when he was here were not as good as the ones that Silva has the luxury of playing alongside. Ive watched Robinho for most of his career and imo i would rate them both equally. On one hand Robinho can do things Silva can never do with a football but on the other Silva is more of a consistent player.... Thats just my view on this anyway.

 

[MCFC BOB]

Silva can do everything Robinho can.

But Robinho can't do everything Silva can.

Silva 100%.

Nicely put.

+1.