Solo/Frontman *FINAL* Mick Jagger Vs David Bowie

[Davs 19]

Re: Solo/Frontman Ian Brown Vs Noel Gallagher Dio Round 40

Pmsl, one can sing the other has never been able too.

Noel.

Curtis, Rotten, Strummer............None of them could really 'sing'....great frontmen though IMO . Noel ? Loved early Oasis and his songwrighting....in terms of charisma not even close to Ian Brown for me.

 

[allan harper]

Re: Solo/Frontman Ian Brown Vs Noel Gallagher Dio Round 40

Pmsl, one can sing the other has never been able too.

Noel.

Curtis, Rotten, Strummer............None of them could really 'sing'....great frontmen though IMO . Noel ? Loved early Oasis and his songwrighting....in terms of charisma not even close to Ian Brown for me.

I've seen them both live, Noel gets the attention of the entire crowd, were as Ian brown, everyone just sings along without ever giving him much attention.

 

[Davs 19]

Re: Solo/Frontman Ian Brown Vs Noel Gallagher Dio Round 40

Pmsl, one can sing the other has never been able too.

Noel.

Curtis, Rotten, Strummer............None of them could really 'sing'....great frontmen though IMO . Noel ? Loved early Oasis and his songwrighting....in terms of charisma not even close to Ian Brown for me.

I've seen them both live, Noel gets the attention of the entire crowd, were as Ian brown, everyone just sings along without ever giving him much attention.

Fair does Al. I've seen the Roses twice and Oasis 4 times. Exactly the other way round for me. Each to their own though....

 

[sniff]

Re: Solo/Frontman Ian Brown Vs Noel Gallagher Dio Round 40

Curtis, Rotten, Strummer............None of them could really 'sing'....great frontmen though IMO . Noel ? Loved early Oasis and his songwrighting....in terms of charisma not even close to Ian Brown for me.

I've seen them both live, Noel gets the attention of the entire crowd, were as Ian brown, everyone just sings along without ever giving him much attention.

Fair does Al. I've seen the Roses twice and Oasis 4 times. Exactly the other way round for me. Each to their own though....

You saw the roses and thought he was good... damm you was off your face. The roses where a great band... but a great frontman he was never....

 

[Davs 19]

Re: Solo/Frontman Ian Brown Vs Noel Gallagher Dio Round 40

I've seen them both live, Noel gets the attention of the entire crowd, were as Ian brown, everyone just sings along without ever giving him much attention.

Fair does Al. I've seen the Roses twice and Oasis 4 times. Exactly the other way round for me. Each to their own though....

You saw the roses and thought he was good... damm you was off your face. The roses where a great band... but a great frontman he was never....

Lol !!! Is true. I think anyone going to watch the Roses and expecting Brown to be a geat singer is missing the point of the Roses though....still a great charismatic frontman for me though.

 

[Stoned Rose]

Re: Solo/Frontman Ian Brown Vs Noel Gallagher Dio Round 40

There are some proper knobs on this Brown v Noel thread.

Noel is very good but has never been a 'frontman'. He was a guitarist in Oasis and has been a solo artist since (with a few musicians 'supporting' him in his 'band' Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds).

Ian Brown cant sing? come back after you've listened to the following one example of many:

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SU71tDrOjfs[/youtube]

And if you want 'live' vocals:

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fkgQQsgqblc[/youtube]

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jDmulWXwfFI&feature=relmfu[/youtube]

And if you want 'frontman cool':

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uDmcvDqsYxc[/youtube]

I like Noel and think he's beltin but Brown absolutely shites on Noel.

 

[BlueTG]

Re: Solo/Frontman Ian Brown Vs Noel Gallagher Dio Round 40

Noel.

 

[LHarper]

Re: Solo/Frontman Ian Brown Vs Noel Gallagher Dio Round 40

Noel

 

[FeedTheGoat10]

Re: Solo/Frontman Ian Brown Vs Noel Gallagher Dio Round 40

Ian Brown. Reckon I'll think Noel in 5-10 years though after he's released a bit more.

 

[Anonymous]

Re: Solo/Frontman Ian Brown Vs Noel Gallagher Dio Round 40

Ian Brown.