Solo/Frontman *FINAL* Mick Jagger Vs David Bowie

[Lucky13]

Re: Solo/Frontman Iggy Pop Vs Lou Reed Round 33

Iggy Pop

 

[nijinsky's fetlocks]

Re: Solo/Frontman Iggy Pop Vs Lou Reed Round 33

Both talentless,and yes i do have some of their music.

Quite possibly the most stupid comment of the week,and I include 'upstairs' in that assessment.
Do you buy a lot of music by artists who you consider 'talentless'?
As a songwriter,Lou Reed.
But as a performer,Iggy Pop.

 

[Manc in London]

Re: Solo/Frontman Iggy Pop Vs Lou Reed Round 33

Both talentless,and yes i do have some of their music.

Quite possibly the most stupid comment of the week,and I include 'upstairs' in that assessment.
Do you buy a lot of music by artists who you consider 'talentless'?
As a songwriter,Lou Reed.
But as a performer,Iggy Pop.

Haha my thoughts too.

Great performer and great showman - Jello Biafra.

In this play-off, as much as I love Lou Reed, Iggy is the best 'frontman' of the two.

 

[guinnessdaze]

Re: Solo/Frontman Iggy Pop Vs Lou Reed Round 33

Both talentless,and yes i do have some of their music.

Quite possibly the most stupid comment of the week,and I include 'upstairs' in that assessment.
Do you buy a lot of music by artists who you consider 'talentless'?
As a songwriter,Lou Reed.
But as a performer,Iggy Pop.

Call me stupid if it makes you feel better,but you never answered the question?

 

[nijinsky's fetlocks]

Re: Solo/Frontman Iggy Pop Vs Lou Reed Round 33

Both talentless,and yes i do have some of their music.

Quite possibly the most stupid comment of the week,and I include 'upstairs' in that assessment.
Do you buy a lot of music by artists who you consider 'talentless'?
As a songwriter,Lou Reed.
But as a performer,Iggy Pop.

Call me stupid if it makes you feel better,but you never answered the question?

I didn't call you stupid - I stated that your comment was,because it is.
Neither artist is talentless,and if you think they are,then buying their music is illogical.
I think I did answer the question by stating that Iggy Pop was a better performer,which is what 'frontman' means.
Apologies if qualifying my decision caused you confusion.

 

[guinnessdaze]

Re: Solo/Frontman Iggy Pop Vs Lou Reed Round 33

Quite possibly the most stupid comment of the week,and I include 'upstairs' in that assessment.
Do you buy a lot of music by artists who you consider 'talentless'?
As a songwriter,Lou Reed.
But as a performer,Iggy Pop.

Call me stupid if it makes you feel better,but you never answered the question?

I didn't call you stupid - I stated that your comment was,because it is.
Neither artist is talentless,and if you think they are,then buying their music is illogical.
I think I did answer the question by stating that Iggy Pop was a better performer,which is what 'frontman' means.
Apologies if qualifying my decision caused you confusion.

My apologies,you did. I still stand by my statement though,I've always said that most artists whether solo or group have the capability of recording a 'gem',something I might buy.

 

[big gaz]

Re: Solo/Frontman Iggy Pop Vs Lou Reed Round 33

Longsight 13 wrote my thoughts on this tie and like him I'll plumb for Iggy as he's more entertaining.

 

[Banned Tosspot]

Re: Solo/Frontman Iggy Pop Vs Lou Reed Round 33

Lou wins.

Round 34

Axl Rose Vs David Johansen

 

[sniff]

Re: Solo/Frontman Axl Rose Vs David Johansen Round 34

Since Johansen was awfull at everything he tried... Axl.

To be fair they are both bellends..

 

[Sam.]

Re: Solo/Frontman Axl Rose Vs David Johansen Round 34

Axl Rose.