Congratulations on the win last night, Chris. Hope you win the final, whoever you play.
Been following NUFC's stadium issues over recent years. A very good mate of mine who's one of the few other foreigners left out here in Russia is a Geordie, a great fan of the Toon and an absolutely super lad generally, and I've discussed it with him. His views are what, from my looking around online, seem to me to be those of most of your fans.
In other words, he loves the location of SJP and would be reluctant to lose that, but recognises you need to upgrade to compete in the modern era. He sees a new stadium on the proposed site as a way to get close to enjoying the best of both worlds. Anyway, good luck to you. FWIW, I agree with both you and the poster immediately above me that you should try to squeeze the capacity to at least 75K.
By the way, would the plan be to play at SJP while the work goes on to build the new ground, even when the overlapping part of the old ground has to be demolished? Spurs had a similar plan but ended up going to Wembley for nearly two full seasons. I know nothing about the practical aspects of construction, but I'm guessing that Spurs baulked at the cost of doing that given that Wembley was available as a relatively nearby alternative.
Presumably, given that there's no stadium you can realistically use in your neck of the woods, your board will pay what it takes to deploy the necessary complex construction solutions. I did see a suggestion somewhere (but I've forgotten where and can't find it now) that you could build a temporary 50,000-seater in Gateshead for the period of construction but I assume that's nonsense.