Vienna_70 said:
I don't think it's right to say that City attracts pessimistic fans per se; it's just that we had 30 years of shit to put up with until HRH Sheikh Mansour took over. This inevitably made us pessimistic.
The next generation won't be (or shouldn't be) pessimistic at all, as they will see the team (hopefully) going from strength to strength. For example, our grandchildren have been to about 15 games between them, but have never seen City lose. They're not going to have to put up with the dross we've experienced for the last three decades, therefore, they won't be pessimistic about our chances. At least, not on a regular basis.
Yes but the generation of fans we are now starting to attract are choosing us because we are winning, so you get a different breed.
It's a chicken vs egg problem.
It's not saying all City fans are pessimists, it's just pondering if certain sets of fans DO have some common traits, and if those traits are brought about by watching the team, or was it those traits that made them choose the team.
A lot of young kids seem to jump onboard whichever team is winning (and that's understandable), but some choose the underdog team. That might be something to do with the nature of the child. Then what happens when the underdog team becomes really good (like City) or the once amazing Liverpool become very ordinary - do you end up with a load of spoilt brats moaning all day because they can't win, or a set of fans who are used to losing, and are still coming to terms with winning things - and still create a tense atmosphere even when we're 2-0 up!