The 10 best City players of all time

[borassic]

Foe(no sentimentality, loved the guy)
dunney
mozza
swp
ireland
rosler
quinn
kinky
robbie
anelka

 

[Dyed Petya]

Would it be my lifetime though? Ain't it a bit blinkered to put coin bell, neil young etc when you never actually saw them play week in week out? Now I don't know how old you are Ric, but I feel like I could only put players down from the last 15 years(being 20).
Not having a go just my thoughts!!

You're judging them objectively by what they achieved at City and in football generally, and by how they were viewed by contemporaries. It depends how much you know about the history of it. If you have a reasonable grasp, them it's perfectly valid.

 

[borassic]

Would it be my lifetime though? Ain't it a bit blinkered to put coin bell, neil young etc when you never actually saw them play week in week out? Now I don't know how old you are Ric, but I feel like I could only put players down from the last 15 years(being 20).
Not having a go just my thoughts!!

You're judging them objectively by what they achieved at City and in football generally, and by how they were viewed by contemporaries. It depends how much you know about the history of it. If you have a reasonable grasp, them it's perfectly valid.

Fair play. I wasn't being argumentative, I just wanted to see the reasoning behind it, which as you say is perfectly valid.

 

[BimboBob]

Corrigan
Ranson
Lake
Bell
Kinky
Barnes
Benarbia
Goater
Bishop

The greatest i've seen play live.Loads i could have added like Lee,Summerbee etc but this is a personal choice.Mine.