Next week should be interesting ;) ;(
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
The Album Review Club - Week #145 - (page 1923) - Tellin' Stories - The Charlatans
- Thread starter RobMCFC
- Start date
Next week should be interesting ;) ;(
mancity2012_eamo
Well-Known Member
Billy Idol?I think it is just the era of the punk and new wave in the late 70's.
There was not many vocalist inspired groups around that time.
Elvis Costello maybe later on but apart from that I cannot think of many Brits at the time from the punk and new wave.
RobMCFC
Well-Known Member
Please reassure me that it’s not The Idles.Next week should be interesting ;) ;(
BlueHammer85
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 13 Oct 2010
- Messages
- 36,709
I do know what B&W means and I agree. I know you nominated The Jam, but this is the same criticism I have about all these bands - why do they have to sound like they have an attitude problem? Why can’t they just step up to the mic and sing? Some of the music on this album is really good but they don’t half spoil it with those vocals.
Like you said, each to their own. I keep using Bon Jovi as an example - not my favourite band but a good example of what, to me, sounds like a great voice. I know plenty on here would disagree, but JBJ, Steve Perry, and Jimi Jamieson of Survivor are examples of the kind of voice I like to hear (outside of those gruff Americana voices, of course :) )
If you put Bon Jovi to this punk sound it would be god awful, I think vocally bands like this, specials, Jam should be sung this way - it adds to the raw and authenticity of punk.
Of course it was of its time, if a band tried it now they’d get slated.
RobMCFC
Well-Known Member
You’ve probably got a point there, but I just find it so hard to listen to (for pleasure).If you put Bon Jovi to this punk sound it would be god awful, I think vocally bands like this, specials, Jam should be sung this way - it adds to the raw and authenticity of punk.
Of course it was of its time, if a band tried it now they’d get slated.
Black&White&BlueMoon Town
Well-Known Member
It really took away from the music on some of the songs for me. On the tracks I mentioned I liked, I thought the vocals were fine.Interesting that you loved the music but not the vocals so the score ended up a lot lower.
Did the vocals really spoil your listens that much.
Ps.Not a criticism each to their own.
mancity2012_eamo
Well-Known Member
You’ve probably got a point there, but I just find it so hard to listen to (for pleasure).
If you put Bon Jovi to this punk sound it would be god awful, I think vocally bands like this, specials, Jam should be sung this way - it adds to the raw and authenticity of punk.
Of course it was of its time, if a band tried it now they’d get slated.
Some of it suits fine. There are some gems on there. I just think some of the album’s vocals sound contrived. Trying too hard.
It is of it’s time although devotees would tell you it’s timeless.
mancity2012_eamo
Well-Known Member
The Clash or The Jam I can handle.This one. Just with some of your takes on this week's album ;). As in I know what's to come.
Pistols and I might give it a miss.
I’m going to be in England from tomorrow and not sure I’ll get as much time to listen anyway.
I do know what B&W means and I agree. I know you nominated The Jam, but this is the same criticism I have about all these bands - why do they have to sound like they have an attitude problem? Why can’t they just step up to the mic and sing? Some of the music on this album is really good but they don’t half spoil it with those vocals.
Like you said, each to their own. I keep using Bon Jovi as an example - not my favourite band but a good example of what, to me, sounds like a great voice. I know plenty on here would disagree, but JBJ, Steve Perry, and Jimi Jamieson of Survivor are examples of the kind of voice I like to hear (outside of those gruff Americana voices, of course :) )
Having said that week about finding the vocals on the jam a bit gimmicky, it is maybe a touch hypocritical of me to argue this point.
But in some ways that's a bit like saying, why can't Peter Howson just gie us a wee nicey picture of the seaside with seaguls in front of a perfect blue sky. There is expression, and a style that goes with it. For me the problem is more when the two don't overlap well. With the Jam I felt it was out of place, but partly swayed by knowing Paul's later ability and tone. With this one it didn't bother me in the slightest. Hammer nails it I think, it sometimes comes with the territory.
If you put Bon Jovi to this punk sound it would be god awful, I think vocally bands like this, specials, Jam should be sung this way - it adds to the raw and authenticity of punk.
Of course it was of its time, if a band tried it now they’d get slated.
Plenty bands still do it now.