The Album Review Club - Week #145 - (page 1923) - Tellin' Stories - The Charlatans

[RobMCFC]

@Coatigan - we can post our guesses on here, right?

 

[Black&White&BlueMoon Town]

Nice to see 3 of my songs in there...especially nice to see Black&White&Blue pick one of them...

Think I was hung out to dry there, so kudos on that.

I'd like to say I have the same excitement for this round, but my late night gut punch is still smarting. The 2016 me reminds me I should have seen it coming too.

I think I'm all out of critical thinking these days if that was the masses are telling me that its not important anymore. Maybe I'll have concepts of a plan on voting here.

 

[Coatigan]

@Coatigan - we can post our guesses on here, right?

Yeah more fun when all transparent.

And top 5 songs off the playlist too, excluding your own (unless swapped).

 

[RobMCFC]

Tough guesses these, given the format.

For example, given that BimboBob nominated Greta Van Fleet, I can only imagine me, OB1 or Gornik selecting this for the playlist, but then none of us would have discovered them here.

1. Deacon Brodie - the Yawpers OB1
2. The Heat Above - Greta Van Feet Coatigan
3. Naden - Bad//Dreems Black&White&Blue
4. The Wheel - Idles Journolud
5. New Sensation- Idles threespires
6. Down to Believing - Alison Moorer Mancitydoogle
7. Blood under the bridge - Frightened Rabbit Saddleworth2
8. I'm so happy I cry - Fantastic Negrito BimboBob
9. Stacy's Mom - Fountains of Wayne RobMCFC
10. Time it's time - Talk Talk Notthreespireshonest
11. The Pan Within - The Waterboys LGWIO
12. Brave new world - war of the worlds Mr.Belfry
13. Under the pressure - war on drugs BlueHammer85
14. Rosalie - Thin Lizzy GornikDaze
15. The enchanter - the budos band bennyboy

Top 5 Songs

1. The Heat Above - Greta Van Feet
2. The Pan Within - The Waterboys
3. Under the Pressure - War on Drugs
4. Stacy's Mom - Fountains of Wayne
5. Down to Believing - Alison Moorer

Looking forward to seeing the results.

 

[mrbelfry]

12. Brave new world - war of the worlds Mr.Belfry

Wow is your opinion of me this low? I think I'm at least cooler than @BlueHammer85

 

[BimboBob]

You didn't pick one of them for the playlist, did you?

Pick my own? That would be madness...

 

[BimboBob]

Tough guesses these, given the format.

For example, given that BimboBob nominated Greta Van Fleet, I can only imagine me, OB1 or Gornik selecting this for the playlist, but then none of us would have discovered them here.

1. Deacon Brodie - the Yawpers OB1
2. The Heat Above - Greta Van Feet Coatigan
3. Naden - Bad//Dreems Black&White&Blue
4. The Wheel - Idles Journolud
5. New Sensation- Idles threespires
6. Down to Believing - Alison Moorer Mancitydoogle
7. Blood under the bridge - Frightened Rabbit Saddleworth2
8. I'm so happy I cry - Fantastic Negrito BimboBob
9. Stacy's Mom - Fountains of Wayne RobMCFC
10. Time it's time - Talk Talk Notthreespireshonest
11. The Pan Within - The Waterboys LGWIO
12. Brave new world - war of the worlds Mr.Belfry
13. Under the pressure - war on drugs BlueHammer85
14. Rosalie - Thin Lizzy GornikDaze
15. The enchanter - the budos band bennyboy

Top 5 Songs

1. The Heat Above - Greta Van Feet
2. The Pan Within - The Waterboys
3. Under the Pressure - War on Drugs
4. Stacy's Mom - Fountains of Wayne
5. Down to Believing - Alison Moorer

Looking forward to seeing the results.

Weird how you have me for an album I didn't even review.

 

[Coatigan]

-	Album	Artist	points	posters	score	nominator
1	Naturally	J.J Cale	23	6	8.14	Ob1
2	Painting of a panic attack	Frightened Rabbit	12	5	6.31	Coat
3	Hats	the Blue Nile	12	4	7.15	Sadds
4	This is the sea	The Waterboys	11	3	7.46	doogle
5	Cold Feet	Rodriguez	9	4	7.73	GaudionM
6	Live Drugs	War on Drugs	9	2	7.75	doogle
7	Crawler	Idles	9	2	6	Coat
8	gun shy	screaming blue messiahs	8	2	7.04	Fog
9	Colour of Spring	Talk Talk	8	2	6.83	Bimbo
10	Car Wheels on a gravel road	Lucinda Williams	7	2	7.44	benny
11	Stop Talking Sense	Talking Heads	6	2	7.25	LGWio
12	viva dead ponies	fatima mansions	6	2	7.09	Eamo
13	JPEG Raw	Gary Clark Jr.	6	2	6.67	B&W
14	A black mile to the surface	manchester orchestra	6	2	6.58	B&W
15	Rising	Rainbow	5	1	7.42	Ob1
16	curtains	Tindersticks	5	1	6.53	Journo
17	Rise and Fall od a midwest princess	Chapel Roan	5	1	5.28	Fog
18	XO	Elliot Smith	4	2	6.39	Big Joe C
19	Odyssey no.5	Powderfinger	4	2	6.36	Southampton
20	never alone with a Schizophrenic	Ian Hunter	4	1	7.18	doogle
21	Rock and Roll Doctor	Little Feet	4	1	7	stoneblue
22	Have you lost your mind	fantastic negrito	4	1	6.72	Gornik
23	Sule Skerry	Erland Cooper	4	1	6.33	Bimbo
24	Dogs at Bay	Bad//Dreems	4	1	6.29	Southampton
25	War Of the Worlds	Jeff Wayne	4	1	6.11	Bimbo
26	Welcome interstate managers	fountains of wayne	4	1	6.07	Fog
27	Strange Times	The Chameleons	3	2	5.46	shackattack
28	Rocks	Aerosmith	3	1	6.87	Ob1
29	let it be	the replacements	3	1	6.86	Fog
30	people on a Sunday	Dominique Dumont	3	1	5.08	Goater
31	American Man	the yawpers	2	2	7.08	Rob
32	pacific street	pale fountains	2	1	6.93	LGWio
33	Dummy	Portishead	2	1	6.79	threespires
34	Crazy on the weekend	Sunhouse	2	1	6.1	doogle
35	America Undefined	Pat Metheny	2	1	5.75	Bill Walker
36	Physical Grafiti	Led Zeppelin	1	1	7.47	Ob1
37	V	the Budos Band	1	1	7.18	Coat
38	battle at garden gate	Greta van Fleet	1	1	6.9	Bimbo
39	down to believing	Alison Moorer	1	1	6.79	threespires
40	Fire in the hole	the tragically hip	1	1	6	Southampton

 

[Coatigan]

Digest them apples.

Big winner, Ob1 with JJ Cale.

 

[RobMCFC]

Weird how you have me for an album I didn't even review.

Now you know I'm honest and not checking the scores before I guess!