The Bluemoon Song Cup 2023

Yep, classics. Kashmir is a staggering song. Led Zep are the ultimate band. And you seldom get a bad offering from Kate Bush. She's an outstanding singer.

Kashmir has a good riff but soon wears off due to the song lasting too long and going nowhere. Kate has made better records as this one is also a bit dull.

Plus Plants wailing is rather annoying which is rather odd as he has a good voice when he doesn't put it on.
 
Kashmir has a good riff but soon wears off due to the song lasting too long and going nowhere. Kate has made better records as this one is also a bit dull.

Plus Plants wailing is rather annoying which is rather odd as he has a good voice when he doesn't put it on.
I'll say nothing, as I'm a bloody good bloke.
 
Kashmir should absolutely monster this. An all time classic from the ultimate hard rock band. Still being sampled and relevant today.


Kate Bush on the other hand is just painful wailing. "OH but she wrote it when she was 14"- guess what, it sounds like it. Dreadful song. If it was Hounds of Love era then ok but this is dire.
They both need to be appreciated, as both are outstanding.
Once you get to this level of track, cheap shots like that don’t carry much weight imho.
 
Kashmir has a good riff but soon wears off due to the song lasting too long and going nowhere. Kate has made better records as this one is also a bit dull.

Plus Plants wailing is rather annoying which is rather odd as he has a good voice when he doesn't put it on.
I must admit I do enjoy Trampled Underfoot and In My Time of Dying more these days.
 
They both need to be appreciated, as both are outstanding.
Once you get to this level of track, cheap shots like that don’t carry much weight imho.
It's not a cheap shot. Early Kate Bush was dreadful. A perfect example of style over substance.

As soon as she introduced rhythm though she became 100 times the musician.
If this had been Running Up That Hill, Cloudbusting or The Hounds of Love then they would have been much worthier contenders
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.