The official EDS and academy thread 2012/13

Status
Not open for further replies.
kippaxchris said:
Boyata is a good young player! He was brilliant in the semi-finals against United after being thrown in at the deep end at a very young age. Just because he scored a couple of own goals doesn't make him an ABSOLUTE LIABILITY just look at Richard Dunne he scored loads of own goals including 2 in 1 match against United and made a lot of mistakes but everyone loved him and still said he was great!
Click to expand...

You are going back a few years to prove to me Boyata is a good young player when since then he has flopped at Bolton on loan and FC Twente on loan. Ask one of our Dutch posters how Boyata was judged in the Dutch press, he was a laughing stock because he was so bad. I wish Boyata had fulfilled his potential but he's clearly not even close to City level if FC Twente send him back because he's so bad there. Nastasic is 3 years younger and 5 times better.
 
LoveCity said:
kippaxchris said:
Boyata is a good young player! He was brilliant in the semi-finals against United after being thrown in at the deep end at a very young age. Just because he scored a couple of own goals doesn't make him an ABSOLUTE LIABILITY just look at Richard Dunne he scored loads of own goals including 2 in 1 match against United and made a lot of mistakes but everyone loved him and still said he was great!
Click to expand...

You are going back a few years to prove to me Boyata is a good young player when since then he has flopped at Bolton on loan and FC Twente on loan. Ask one of our Dutch posters how Boyata was judged in the Dutch press, he was a laughing stock because he was so bad. I wish Boyata had fulfilled his potential but he's clearly not even close to City level if FC Twente send him back because he's so bad there. Nastasic is 3 years younger and 5 times better.
Click to expand...

I don't think anyone is debating whether Nastasic is/will be better, because that much is obvious. I think he's just saying that he used to be good, and he's still young, so if he can recapture his old form like against united he may be a decent player in the future.
 
feel sorry for reikik, apparently every game he as played hes been awful, and we all know what blackburn fans are like, already getting on his back calling him 'terrible'. Hes been playing left back/left mid, and in my opinion he should always be a centre back.
 
My personal experience with Rekik is that he's a ****. And he likes to party too much.
 
Joe hart's itchy scalp said:
I don't think anyone is debating whether Nastasic is/will be better, because that much is obvious. I think he's just saying that he used to be good, and he's still young, so if he can recapture his old form like against united he may be a decent player in the future.
Click to expand...

But he made it out like Boyata is still the player he was when he played against United when he's actually regressed. If he's a complete liability at the 4th/5th best team in Holland, what chance does he have at City? He's 22 now, not a baby anymore, and the first team that makes a cash offer for him City will snatch their hand off I think.

bapi said:
My personal experience with Rekik is that he's a ****. And he likes to party too much.
Click to expand...

What personal experience is this? I've heard the rumours about Razak but nothing like this about Rekik before.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
✖
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.