The Smiths & Morrissey thread

Been revisiting Strangeways, Here We Come a lot recently. Always preferred The Queen Is Dead personally but noticed that all Smiths’ members (I think?) felt that Strangeways was their masterpiece? Both absolutely brilliant albums in their own way.
 
Been revisiting Strangeways, Here We Come a lot recently. Always preferred The Queen Is Dead personally but noticed that all Smiths’ members (I think?) felt that Strangeways was their masterpiece? Both absolutely brilliant albums in their own way.
Certainly Johnny and Mike have said that.
Always TQID for me 10/10 with the other 3 on 9.9/10 lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ric
Certainly Johnny and Mike have said that.
Always TQID for me 10/10 with the other 3 on 9.9/10 lol
Shouldn’t really include them in this, but where would you rank Hatful of Hollow, Louder Than Bombs, The World Won’t Listen and, erm, Rank if you had to give a top 8?
 
Shouldn’t really include them in this, but where would you rank Hatful of Hollow, Louder Than Bombs, The World Won’t Listen and, erm, Rank if you had to give a top 8?
Great question!
Wouldn't rate Louder The Bombs high as it is a compilation of 2 compilations (originally an import) although does have a few alternative versions.
Rank as a live album, never been a lover of live albums. Bought Rank and Nocturne by The Banshees (as I was there) and no other... Played Rank maybe twice in total all the way through.

1. The Queen Is Dead
2 Hatfull of Hollow
3. The Smiths
4. Meat is Murder
5. Strangeways
6. World won't listen
7. Louder than bombs
8. Rank

Between 3, 4 and 5 there is a hair width between them. But that is my preference.
 
Great question!
Wouldn't include Louder The Bombs as it is a compilation of 2 compilations!
Rank as a live album, never been a lover of live albums. Bought Rank and Nocturne by The Banshees (as I was there) and no other... Played Rank maybe twice in total all the way through.

1. The Queen Is Dead
2 Hatfull of Hollow
3. The Smiths
4. Meat is Murder
5. Strangeways
6. World won't listen
7. Louder than bombs
8. Rank

Between 3, 4 and 5 there is a hair width between them. But that is my preference.
Good man. I really like Rank, but maybe it’s unfair to include it in this comparison. Not really like for like, although then again neither is much of the rest of the list!
For what it’s worth (purely in terms of what I listen to most rather than artistic merit):
1) The Queen Is Dead
2) Meat Is Murder
3) Strangeways, Here We Come
4) Louder Than Bombs
5) The Smiths
6) Hatful of Hollow
7) The World Won’t Listen
 
Good man. I really like Rank, but maybe it’s unfair to include it in this comparison. Not really like for like, although then again neither is much of the rest of the list!
For what it’s worth (purely in terms of what I listen to most rather than artistic merit):
1) The Queen Is Dead
2) Meat Is Murder
3) Strangeways, Here We Come
4) Louder Than Bombs
5) The Smiths
6) Hatful of Hollow
7) The World Won’t Listen
Hatful Of Hollow no 7????
*Resigns as a mod...... * lol
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.