The Smiths or Oasis?

[BlueMoon93]

Oasis cos The Smiths were a bit before my time tbh. My dad would go for The Smiths though.

 

[jimharri]

 

[LongLang]

Oasis, never much cared for the smiths. all seems a bit depressing to me.
i like smiling and swaggering.

 

[shadygiz]

smiths.....will never be equalled

 

[Swales lives]

Even Noel wouldn't compare Manchester's greatest ever band (The Smiths) to his old outfit.
It's a silly thread. Please delete it.

 

[mr t]

I love both but The Smiths were totally original - something that Oasis could never claim to be.

I never get sick of The Smiths - some of the best lyrics ever to be written are contained in their tunes.

 

[4HeatonsBlue]

Anybody who says Oasis is a fucking idiot

Viva La Moz..

 

[johnmc]

Oasis. They were coming out just when i was getting into music and they were city fans which helped and I got well into them, first gig i saw was oasis at the winter gardens the day Whats the story game out, i was 14.

The Smiths were from another era and were never someone i was gonna listen too before i was 20. Now i have matured a bit and my music tastes have a bit and i appreciate the smiths. They are very good but i could never just put a record of theirs on from start to finish.

Like comparing chalk and cheese though

 

[BimboBob]

The Smiths.End of.

She's got a sister and on the back of her she has a blister? What?

 

[mr t]

Oasis. They were coming out just when i was getting into music and they were city fans which helped and I got well into them, first gig i saw was oasis at the winter gardens the day Whats the story game out, i was 14.

The Smiths were from another era and were never someone i was gonna listen too before i was 20. Now i have matured a bit and my music tastes have a bit and i appreciate the smiths. They are very good but i could never just put a record of theirs on from start to finish.
Like comparing chalk and cheese though

That is the most ridiculous statement I've read today - I'm lost for words.