The Smiths or Oasis?

[RoqueSantaBoozeCruz]

Disagree

Backs up that they havnt brought out music that is BETTER than the first two albums.

But then again, WHICH BAND has brought out stuff that is better than oasis first two albums since 1996?? I bet there's not many.

Daft Punk all 3 for a kick off.

Buckcherry's debut was a proper rock n roll record too, that was about 1999.

Moston_blue may be stuck in the Manchester or plain boring guitar/indie style.

 

[alanjames24]

no contest, obviously oasis.

No contest, obviously THE SMITHS!!!

 

[Clevers]

The Smiths have the edge for me

 

[Moston_blue]

Daft Punk all 3 for a kick off.

Buckcherry's debut was a proper rock n roll record too, that was about 1999.

Moston_blue may be stuck in the Manchester or plain boring guitar/indie style.

No not really, I like a lot of things, Rock n Roll is the fave though. Im just pointing out that not many people/bands or whatever have made anything better than oasis first two albums since they came out.

Another thing as well. How do you determine the 'best' band? Its like who is the bigger football club. Do you go off comparing individual songs, record sales, worldwide fans?? Its all opinions.

See you at OT boom boom

 

[buzzer1]

The Smiths for me although Oasis are sound.

The best by the Smiths are The Boy With The Thorn.., and ASK.

 

[crumpsallblue]

can somebody name the best 10 Smiths Songs?

how soon is now

reel around the fountain

this charming man

hand in glove

girlfriend in a coma

suffer little children

cemetary gates

queen is dead

bigmouth strikes again

there is a light that never goes out

unhappy birthday

last night i dreamt

the boy with the thorn in his side

rusholme ruffians

london

paint a vulgar picture
--------------------------------------
you want anymore mate ;)

you forgot "every days like sunday"

 

[Swales lives]

how soon is now

reel around the fountain

this charming man

hand in glove

girlfriend in a coma

suffer little children

cemetary gates

queen is dead

bigmouth strikes again

there is a light that never goes out

unhappy birthday

last night i dreamt

the boy with the thorn in his side

rusholme ruffians

london

paint a vulgar picture
--------------------------------------
you want anymore mate ;)

you forgot "every days like sunday"

Because that isn't a Smiths song

 

[crumpsallblue]

correct.. i'l get me coat!

 

[acquiesce]

Oasis purely because they soundtracked my formative years. Had I been in my teens in the 80's it probably would have been a different story. Many a summer night was lost listening to Oasis and dreaming of being in Manchester.

 

[the--dud]

The Smiths are legendary, Oasis were(are?) a good band. Love The Smiths!