UEFA Ask City Football Group to Divest its ownership of Girona

"Not sure this was needed, makes it sound like we’ve been match fixing."

No it's does not say that in anyway, to have two clubs in the same competition with the same ownership is not good for anyone.

This is the major problem with multi club ownership and personally I am totally against it.

There are huge positives in terms of cherry picking the best up and coming talent in each continent but then when it comes competitions there is a serious issue.

And with Liverpool and the rags wanting to go down the same route the problem is only going to get worse.

I think UEFA are correct with the decision but when I read the article with “ severely tested & collusion “ it feels like the narrative would make people think the collusion they think could happen has happened.
 
The article can't even get the % CFG owns of City right so I doubt the rest of the article is correct either
 
Yes completely agree. Its wrong on many levels and before City started doing it the vast majority of fans on here would think the same.
Yep. Don't agree with this CFG multi-club ownership thing at all. If we want to start our own teams like New York City for instance, that has its problems but is mostly fine. But moving in and buying up clubs with long histories feels wrong to me. And for every success story like Girona there's a story like Troyes AC, where they've been relegated twice in two seasons and you've got fans ironically singing "Merci City!" as they go down. The pros don't outweigh the cons imo.
 
Yep. Don't agree with this CFG multi-club ownership thing at all. If we want to start our own teams like New York City for instance, that has its problems but is mostly fine. But moving in and buying up clubs with long histories feels wrong to me. And for every success story like Girona there's a story like Troyes AC, where they've been relegated twice in two seasons and you've got fans ironically singing "Merci City!" as they go down. The pros don't outweigh the cons imo.
It's a legitimate way to spread some of our overheads and is proving a good way to develop players, if not for our direct benefit then for profit in our P&L. It's not going away.

Girona had never been in the top flight before our involvement so we are not adversely affecting their fans who have just witnessed a title challenge for the first time.

I think everyone acknowledges mistakes were made for Troyes, but I'm pretty confident they will be able to make an immediate return to the second tier next season (which is roughly their natural level), and could easily kick on from there.

In my opinion though, the journalists that have covered Troyes have treated Gironas achievements as an outlier and Troyes as the embodiment of our multi club ownership. For me, it's the other way round - Troyes is the outlier.

Palermo are probably the European club with the richest history (outside of City) in the group, but were in Serie C when we got involved. They're currently competing in the Play Offs to go up to Serie A.

Lommel are also in the play offs to get up to the top tier of Belgian football.

New York, Melbourne, Mumbai, Yokohama have all had success. Yokohama are due to play the 2nd leg of the Asian Champions League Final this weekend.

I wouldn't want City to be used as a means for another club to have success, but I don't think our success needs to come at the detriment of the other clubs. It should be a mutually beneficial arrangement.

With that being said, I don't like what has happened in China, as even though we've taken a third tier team to the top flight, we relocated it just to make more money.
 
What has Eric Garcia got to do with us?
He's a former player of ours now at Barca and loaned by them to Girona. Been the mainstay of their defence all season. Just pointing out that they are going to loose probably their three best players and as we cannot loan them any players and the top flight in Spain won't either it's going to be a tough year for them. Not only in the CL but in La Liga.
 
I imagine because Salzburg and Leipzig were not likely to win it or upset the domestic apple cart by usurping Bayern or PSG?

What people don't realise, is Salzburg and Leipzig are actually in two different countries. One is in Austria, the other in Germany.

Whereas, Manchester and Girona are both in Abu Dhabi.
 
There was no such stipulation for Red Bull Salzburg when they qualified for the CL alongside Leipzig was there? What's the difference. If I was the CFG that's what I'd be asking. If there was then fair enough.

I imagine because Salzburg and Leipzig were not likely to win it or upset the domestic apple cart by usurping Bayern or PSG?

What people don't realise, is Salzburg and Leipzig are actually in two different countries. One is in Austria, the other in Germany.

Whereas, Manchester and Girona are both in Abu Dhabi.

Hate to interrupt yet another conspiracy theory but yes, Salzburg and Leipzig did have to do this, a Swiss judge went through both companies and made them seperate all shared assets and people who worked for the group/both clubs in scouting or business roles were made to just work for 1.

Because they did that, they didn't fail article 5.

IMO the biggest potential problem for CFG is sponsorship. The RB clubs had to split their sponsorships in a way that satisfied UEFA's CFCB. Shared sponsors is kind of core to the whole CFG project.
 
Last edited:
Hate to interrupt yet another conspiracy theory but yes, Salzburg and Leipzig did have to do this, a Swiss judge went through both companies and made them seperate all shared assets and people who worked for the group/both clubs in scouting or business roles were made to just work for 1.

Because they did that, they didn't fail article 5.

IMO the biggest potential problem for CFG is sponsorship. The RB clubs had to split their sponsorships in a way that satisfied UEFA's CFCB. Shared sponsors is kind of core to the whole CFG project.

Thanks for the clarification. I didn't really think both were in Abu Dhabi though.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top