TonyM said:
I actually think this is a great signing for united. IMO VG knows his defence is too poor to win anything and the best they can do is 5th....so forget about the defence and beef up the attack. Beyond the top 3 or 4 clubs the rest of the league can't punish poor defending often enough and in most cases attacking is your best defence. So the win the league behind the top 4 and then try to draw against the top sides hoping that one of them fall out.
I obviously hope they screw it up but if they could only make one 1 big signing then I think they went for the right guy.
It's hard to go all out attack if you're constantly having to cover a shit defence though. So far, he's been playing 3-5-2, which is what he did with the Dutch because their defenders weren't good enough. But they can't play that formation and fit Di Maria into the team, unless he's actually gonna use him as a wing back. 4-4-2 puts Mata out of position. 4-3-3 puts Rooney out of position. 4-2-3-1 puts Rooney or Mata out of position. Ironically, I think the only way they can fit them all in the team is to copy our system of 4-2-2-2 with Mata and Di Maria being given licence to roam. But it could be a disaster with their lightweight midfield covering a shit defence.