United thread 2017/18

[I'm With Stupid]

The donut thief is a very good player but I doubt anyone would have him in our team over Eddie.

He's probably the better shot-stopper, but he wouldn't be as good as Ederson in anything else. I guess the question depends on whether it's how many of our players would get into their team, managed by Mourinho, or how many of their players would get in our team managed by Pep. For the former, there's definitely a lot, although he'd probably still insist on having big lumps like Matic and Lukaku over actual cultured players.

 

[Nightmare Walking]

The donut thief is a very good player but I doubt anyone would have him in our team over Eddie.

Eddie looks fantastic but he is unproven in comparison to the donut thief. He has been their one world class player for a few years now and is atguably the best keeper in the world at present.

 

[Deleted member 13905]

 

[I'm With Stupid]

Eddie looks fantastic but he is unproven in comparison to the donut thief. He has been their one world class player for a few years now and is atguably the best keeper in the world at present.

Only because this guy's injured.

 

[Grassland Blue]

So with everyone fit, how many of their squad would actually get in our first team? The donut thief would be the stand out one. Pogba is a very good player and I think he will come good. Yet he is not as good as Silva or KDB in the attacking midfield roles and and no chance he gets in, in front of Fernandinho in the deeper role.
Bailly is better than Otto I reckon.

There is no excuse for us not spanking them. We are far, far better than them.

Eddie is better than the Llama.

 

[remember arthur mann]

Eddie looks fantastic but he is unproven in comparison to the donut thief. He has been their one world class player for a few years now and is atguably the best keeper in the world at present.

Looks ok with a ten man bus parked in front of him with very negative hoofball. Play him in an attractive, attacking, expansive team like City, then we would probably not be sitting on top of the Prem !!

 

[laserblue]

The donut thief is a very good player but I doubt anyone would have him in our team over Eddie.

This.

 

[Daz_Blue]

Phil Jones is selling his own chocolate bars now

 

[TheThirdDeano]

Fucking hell I can't believe how many of you collude in the illusion the donut thief is anything other than a hollywood keeper.

 

[KentBlue]

Looks ok with a ten man bus parked in front of him with very negative hoofball. Play him in an attractive, attacking, expansive team like City, then we would probably not be sitting on top of the Prem !!

He's okay for the rags, but never in a million years is he a Pep player. Eddie is taylor-made for the way we are playing; he's like a sweeper. He gives us an extra option (I just don't like that bloody great big tattoo on his neck).