They are not very reliable for many reasons. I'll demonstrate.below
There are multiple problems with Politifacts. It's quite obvious they lean heavily left once you examine their ratings closely.
So let's do just that: Examine some examples of seemingly questionable fact-checks
Tucker Carlson:
Claim:
Says Kamala Harris "said she believed that Joe Biden committed sexual assault against various women.”
Politifacts Conclusion: MOSTLY FALSE.
Now let's dig deeper:
- Over the span of a few days in 2019, four women accused Joe Biden of inappropriate touching, holding or kissing. To which Harris said she believed those women.
- On April 2, 2019, then-candidate Kamala Harris said about these four women: “I believe them, and I respect them being able to tell their story and having the courage to do it
Why then did Politifacts conclude Carlson was Mostly False?
Apparently, Tucker's claim is MOSTLY false coz the women did not explicitly claim sexual assault. "Some explicitly said it wasn’t.:"
Now, here Politifacts gave us this definition of sexual assault.
Sexual assault refers to "sexual contact or behavior that occurs without explicit consent of the victim,"
So we know one element '
without consent' was satisfied. The question is now whether the acts were sexual contact or behaviors and whether the women felt they were victimized.
Now let's fact check Politifacts here:
Let's examine those contacts that were NOT sexual assault. In 2016 after sharing her sexual assault story, Caitlin Caruso claimed Biden "hugged her just a little bit too long and then laid his hand on her thighs."
Here's how she described it to the NY Times "
It doesn’t even really cross your mind that such a person would dare perpetuate harm like that,”
In what way does the above description NOT implicate Sexual Assault? But apparently, because she didn't actually bust out the words 'sexual assault. Politifacts concluded it is false to characterize it as such.
Below is a link to the 4 womens story from.left leaning 'The Cut"
This Carlson claim by most fair standard is ALL true.
It's True about what Harris said. 2. True about what Harris was implying when she said it. And 3. True about the experience of at least 2 of those women.
Yet Politifacts concludes it's most false.
Thats Politifacts for you.
I have a few more examples on both Tucker and Maddow I can use as an examples. But this is getting long and I doubt you are really interested in them.
You should read the fact checks themselves! Not just the summaries or graphs.
Let me know if you want the writeup on the Maddow's ridiculous Mostly True fact check and how it's problematic.
To conclude here is Larry Elder's descriptions of Politifacts fact checking his claims in which they concluded his claims were FALSE!
Enjoy:)
: