I wasn't upset when she was replaced by Roebuck who I thought was a very good keeper and was unlucky to lose her place to illness.Don't recall her being good with reaction saves, particularly. I rate both Keating and Yamashita better in that dept. For agility I rate Keating higher than both.
I, also, remember Bardsley being poor with her feet.
As a standard non-specialty keeper, sure, she was as good as it got.
Keating for me played very well last season, yes there was some mistakes but in the main she looked like she was our #1 for the next 10 years and then we buy two keepers and drop her for Yamahita, who is a decent standard as well.
For me, all we did was add a problem in selection by signing a current Int keeper.