Var debate 2019/20

[deegee33]

We know what’s going on so do the majority of fans of other clubs,but the premier league don’t seem to give to fucks,it’s all about the desperation to get them into that forth spot,next Sunday’s game should be an interesting one shouldn’t it ..

I trust that next Sunday's match will fall as an extreme embarrassment to the red scum. I'm withdrawing myself from bluemoon for a week, stay positive my friends.

 

[give it to gordon]

Its early ! But can a attacker be off side if it comes of a defender last ? Sure I have seen players score when its come of a defender last making the attacker on side .

 

[manimanc]

Its early ! But can a attacker be off side if it comes of a defender last ? Sure I have seen players score when its come of a defender last making the attacker on side .

You're right mate but they disallowed it as I think they said he was interfering with play and distracted the donut thief which was bollocks as de gea was already going the wrong way.
But it was utd, it was the last minute and them things can't happen anymore.

 

[Gazza]

Its early ! But can a attacker be off side if it comes of a defender last ? Sure I have seen players score when its come of a defender last making the attacker on side .

It's got to be an intentional touch off the defender.

 

[MillionMilesAway]

It's got to be an intentional touch off the defender.

It does, but an intentional touch doesn't always play someone onside again.

If a player is offside, he can be played on by an attempt to play the ball, but not if the attempt is just a block. Kane got one off Lovren a year or so ago, but was 20 yards out and an attempted clearance.

It's why a keeper saving a shot doesn't play someone onside. Maguire could be viewed as blocking, and if so, that would not play someone onside. Ifs and coulds!

 

[ali benarbia's studs]

this selective angle that they use is unjust, they used it with spurs in CL. it s wrong as all other angles prove their lie. everton were robbed imo. a joke,offside if he touched ball,again imo.

 

[Gazza]

It does, but an intentional touch doesn't always play someone onside again.

If a player is offside, he can be played on by an attempt to play the ball, but not if the attempt is just a block. Kane got one off Lovren a year or so ago, but was 20 yards out and an attempted clearance.

It's why a keeper saving a shot doesn't play someone onside. Maguire could be viewed as blocking, and if so, that would not play someone onside. Ifs and coulds!

It's funny how ifs and coulds always turn into will and shoulds when VARring United and Liverpool.

 

[MillionMilesAway]

It's funny how ifs and coulds always turn into will and shoulds when VARring United and Liverpool.

Cynic!

 

[half & half derby scarf]

I don't know what much else there is to say about VAR. Great technology destroyed by new legislation and implementation.
All the great goals and celebrations now obliterated from history. Ours v Spurs in Cl and more recently Rice for WHU v Sheff U away, Iheanacho v Norwich away, Maguire OG v Everton yesterday. In any sane world all those goals and many more are given.
Yet, we'll have a review at the end of the season, they will say toenails offside are now going to be deemed onside and there will be no accountability for the hundreds of incorrect decisions this season.

 

[Gazza]

I don't know what much else there is to say about VAR. Great technology destroyed by new legislation and implementation.
All the great goals and celebrations now obliterated from history. Ours v Spurs in Cl and more recently Rice for WHU v Sheff U away, Iheanacho v Norwich away, Maguire OG v Everton yesterday. In any sane world all those goals and many more are given.
Yet, we'll have a review at the end of the season, they will say toenails offside are now going to be deemed onside and there will be no accountability for the hundreds of incorrect decisions this season.

and when someone is a full toe offside, they'll say it's still too close, then a foot, then a leg. Football is an analogue sport being (mis)controlled by a digital system.