VAR Discussion Thread

They're just taking the piss now, by coming out and saying it was the correct decision to allow the Wirtz goal.
What everyone at home saw wasn't real and we should never trust our eyes again.
Football's absolutely f@cked these days, and all because they wanted to bring in another manipulation tool to try and doctor results.
Absolutely ruined our national sport
 
Would happily scrap it, but I think that horse has already bolted. So just a halfway house suggestion and it would restrict the maximum number of times it could be used

In terms of justifying it's existence, I'm sure PIGMOL have lots of stats to back it up and say that they are getting more decisions right
The stats are available to show how good it’s is a nice little earner for the PiGMOL staff and suppliers
 
"BBC Sport understands that the discrepancy lies in the choice of frame by the broadcaster.

The VAR selected the frame when Bradley first made contact with the ball, not when it left his foot.

The broadcaster froze the picture one frame later which gave the impression Wirtz was more obviously offside."

Sure sure. When you can select the frame, it's just another chance to manipulate a result. Honestly, it's seemingly impossible to ruin something so fucking good as football - and yet here they are...
Maintained this from the outset, the VAR can determine the kick point to suit their agenda now with SAOT they can change the recommendation of the software if, they think it is wrong, this is clearly what happened for the Newcastle and Liverpool goals bent bastards
 
So the verdict on Wirtz offside goal is in…

The video assistant referee did not make a mistake by awarding Florian Wirtz's goal for Liverpool at Fulham, the Premier League's Key Match Incidents Panel has said.

It was a controversial decision because images shown on television gave the impression that Wirtz was ahead of the last defender by a clear margin.

The VAR selected the frame when Bradley first made contact with the ball, not when it left his foot.

But the KMI Panel unanimously backed Madley, saying: "The VAR intervention to award the goal was supported as correct, given the tight margin of the offside call and thicker offside lines used for these incredibly tight calls."

So just as City’s (Semenyo’s) goal was manipulated to be offside, Liverpool’s (Wirtz’s) goal was manipulated to be onside.

You couldn’t make this up! “Oh yes you can” says VAR.
 
So the verdict on Wirtz offside goal is in…

The video assistant referee did not make a mistake by awarding Florian Wirtz's goal for Liverpool at Fulham, the Premier League's Key Match Incidents Panel has said.

It was a controversial decision because images shown on television gave the impression that Wirtz was ahead of the last defender by a clear margin.

The VAR selected the frame when Bradley first made contact with the ball, not when it left his foot.

But the KMI Panel unanimously backed Madley, saying: "The VAR intervention to award the goal was supported as correct, given the tight margin of the offside call and thicker offside lines used for these incredibly tight calls."

So just as City’s (Semenyo’s) goal was manipulated to be offside, Liverpool’s (Wirtz’s) goal was manipulated to be onside.

You couldn’t make this up! “Oh yes you can” says VAR.
Just read that article and it is totally damning. They don't realise it, but it reads like Trump propaganda. So many conflicting statements. never has a truer word been spoken about VAR than "They make it up as they go along".
 
So the verdict on Wirtz offside goal is in…

The video assistant referee did not make a mistake by awarding Florian Wirtz's goal for Liverpool at Fulham, the Premier League's Key Match Incidents Panel has said.

It was a controversial decision because images shown on television gave the impression that Wirtz was ahead of the last defender by a clear margin.

The VAR selected the frame when Bradley first made contact with the ball, not when it left his foot.

But the KMI Panel unanimously backed Madley, saying: "The VAR intervention to award the goal was supported as correct, given the tight margin of the offside call and thicker offside lines used for these incredibly tight calls."

So just as City’s (Semenyo’s) goal was manipulated to be offside, Liverpool’s (Wirtz’s) goal was manipulated to be onside.

You couldn’t make this up! “Oh yes you can” says VAR.
The explanation of the Wirtz decision has inadvertently let the cat out of the bag that the broadcasters aren't mandated to use the same frame VAR did in their decision process. Did anyone know that before they told us? I certainly didn't.

That allows the TV companies to control that narrative and it means there is zero transparency in the process because fans and viewers can't be sure what they are seeing on TV is a true reflection of the decision. It basically means they can make a really tight call look well on or well off as it suits, and more importantly it means they can just flat out lie and show whatever frame they want.
 
We will be heading into NFL territory soon with 4 quarters and game day lasting 6 hrs.
Interesting that you use the NFL as a comparison because the NFL have used one version of 'VAR' or another for 40 years. Yet apart from one experimental season, when it was then quickly dropped, they do not use video replay on pass interference calls. Coaches can't challenge PI, and although there are some technicalities when it's not strictly true, generally speaking, the video review booth do not get involved in PI. Whatever the call made on the field, stands.

The reason for this is that PI is the one call in the game that is the most subjective. When two players are fighting for the ball, there is nearly always contact by both players on the other. In a high number of incidents you could make a case for a foul either way, or not at all and have evidence to support it. The NFL feels that by allowing video officials to get involved in PI, you'd simply be replacing one man's subjective view with another man's subjective view. So they choose to leave the call solely to the on field officials.

I'm sure it won't happen, but it would be nice if football could maybe consider learning some lessons from that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: es1
Var : “fuck, we can’t give city this goal- what do we do? Get Webb on the phone.

*ring ring*

Webb : “just give me a min, got to clear up the pisscans bedsheets, he’s done it again, umm hello? , yes fuck City, fuck them up their arse, just say offside, that’ll be alright as we don’t have to say anything hehehe, oh shit, the pisscan now looks like a blue waffle… pisscan? pisscan?……nooooooooooo.”
 
They're just taking the piss now, by coming out and saying it was the correct decision to allow the Wirtz goal.
What everyone at home saw wasn't real and we should never trust our eyes again.
Football's absolutely f@cked these days, and all because they wanted to bring in another manipulation tool to try and doctor results.
Absolutely ruined our national sport

I find it funny as fuck that they introduced VAR to give definite answers after broadcasters with video replay and freeze frame showed that decisions (surprise, surprise) were sometimes wrong, especially in close situations, and now they are having to explain why VAR decisions are right and the broadcasters are wrong. I mean, just what is the fucking point? For the love of God, it's a sport not an international diplomatic incident.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top