'We have a squad capable of top 6 at least'

Last year e were'nt really overwhelmed about a ninth place because of our start (we got cocky and wanted more). We had problems with injuries last year too.

The thing about last year was building for this year. We bought many-non english players and players like Elano, Corlika, Garrido, Boj,Petrov etc hopefully would gain experience from one year in the Prem League. Obviously it was too tough to be good a whole year and adding some tumult between the owner and the manager the end was qtuie bad and the 8-1 embarrasing. The Middlesborugh fight was though not too important and I can understand that the players (if they liked the current management) was a bit fed up.

However the squad Hughes inherited, (if Hughes thought that the city squad was shite then he wouldn't hva come) was young players like Ireland, Johnsson, Gelson, Sturridge etc getting better and gaining more experience.

It was Elano, petrov, Corluka, Garrido, Gelson (again), Caceido getting some experience from EPL and hopefully som of them could be better mentally this year.

Add to that, City dreamsigning SWP who was just what we needed a great right-winger, Robinho one of the best players in the world, Jo aproven goalscorer, and some depth in the squad with Zabaleta, Kompany, Ben-Haim. We should be much better this year and would of course fight for a top-6 spot. Just look at the bookies odds before the season.

Of course even if it's Sven, Mark or Stuart who buy players all of them won't come good because of various reasons. Some won't settle, some foreign players are just not cut for EPL but that's not always the easiest thing to know when you buy a quality players, some of ther are just a pure mistake buying but if you buy three and two comes out great and one is a failure I think it's pretty good.

Anyway I think it's really thinking backwards saying we can't compete for a top 6 place. To say that we should be big 4 is too much but we should compete with Everton, Portshmouth and Villa up there.
 
We may well have spent 80 million in the summer, but lets look at what that money went on. 56.5 million was spen on Tal Ben Haim (5 million), Jo (19 million) and Robinho (32.5 million) ALL of which didn't play yesterday. So when they said '80 million pounds worth of talent on display' its not exactly true. Sure SWP, Kompany and Zabaletta came in for the rest (not sure on how much each), but its clear to see that the team hughes has to pick is not of the 80 million quality that people quote. hughes' squad SHOULD be doing better than we are now and we can turn things around. Petrov's injury is a huge blow and he should never have played 90 mins for bulgaria straight after comign back from a bad injury. We're missing his play down the left lots, forcing us to use our middle men out wide. What is it with out strikers?! We haev loads of them and yet none are worth 20 a season at the moment. Benji tried hard but never looked like scoring and i was hoping Caicedo would start after a good 15 mins in spain. Vass has lost his pace, cant (and wont) shoot and the cross he put in that went straight out was truely awful. In my opinion the two worst players on yesterday were Ball and Richards. when watching the game i had no confidence in richards making the right tackle and ball is truely terrible. yes his throw landed at the back heel of caicedo but other than that he was far too wasteful of the ball. We all know we need a left back, Garrido has improved but needs to have a better man challenging him for a place and a centre back to partner dunne to give micah time to cool his head a bit would be great. I think on a whole the squad is good enough and when we have an injury free squad we'll go places. Unfortunately i dont think sparky will be in charge to see it happen. Sorry for the essay.
 
Godfather said:
NO WE BLOODY DONT!

i have heard this many a time readng through these forums. you only have to compare us to Everton who definatley (although thread bare) have a top 6 team. would you choose our players in respective positons over Joseph Yobo, Phil Jagielka, Joleon Lescott, Leigthon Baines, Mikel Arteta, Tim Cahill, Feillani, Yakubu, even Tim Howard?

I know we have to be a bit biased some times but we do not have a squad anywhere near capable of finishing top 6. Top 10 if we are lucky.


YES WE DO...... well top 10 at least.

What we dont have is the right man at the top to gell a squad with massive individual ability and potential into a top 6 challenging squad.
 
Ok so if you look at last year this time when we started to struggle.

Still no SWP, Kompany, Benjani, Cas to choose from

On the bench we had the likes of Etuhu and Geovanni

I think we should be at least almost as good this season even when we can't use Robinho. We're still in the relegation battle having Robinho in our squad.

15 dec
Final Manchester City 4 - 2 Bolton Wanderers City of Manchester Stadium (40,506

1 Andreas Isaksson (G)
22 Richard Dunne (D)
3 Michael Ball (D)
2 Micah Richards (D)
16 Vedran Corluka (D)
21 Dietmar Hamann (M)
15 Martin Petrov (M)
6 Michael Johnson (M)
28 Fernandes Gelson (M)
12 Darius Vassell (ST)
10 Rolando Bianchi (ST)

22 dec

Final Aston Villa 1 - 1 Manchester City Villa Park (41,455

25 Joe Hart (G)
22 Richard Dunne (D)
3 Michael Ball (D)
4 Nedum Onuoha (D)
2 Micah Richards (D)
21 Dietmar Hamann (M)
15 Martin Petrov (M)
11 Blumer Elano (M)
28 Fernandes Gelson (M)
12 Darius Vassell (ST)
10 Rolando Bianchi (ST)

27 dec
Final Manchester City 2 - 2 Blackburn Rovers City of Manchester Stadium (42,112)

25 Joe Hart (G)
22 Richard Dunne (D)
3 Michael Ball (D)
4 Nedum Onuoha (D)
2 Micah Richards (D)
16 Vedran Corluka (D)
15 Martin Petrov (M)
7 Stephen Ireland (M)
28 Fernandes Gelson (M)
12 Darius Vassell (ST)
10 Rolando Bianchi (ST)
 
We short in to many departments to even think about the top 6. I'd like to think that witha fit Petrov and Johnson we'd be knocking on the door but the defensive shambles this season leads me to think otherwise.

The way the league is looking this year anything is still achievable if we can get some momentum. And decent players in.
 
Godfather said:
NO WE BLOODY DONT!

i have heard this many a time readng through these forums. you only have to compare us to Everton who definatley (although thread bare) have a top 6 team. would you choose our players in respective positons over Joseph Yobo, Phil Jagielka, Joleon Lescott, Leigthon Baines, Mikel Arteta, Tim Cahill, Feillani, Yakubu, even Tim Howard?

I know we have to be a bit biased some times but we do not have a squad anywhere near capable of finishing top 6. Top 10 if we are lucky.


our players are better than them mentioned

hughes doesnt know how to manage them
 
drc said:
Ok so if you look at last year this time when we started to struggle.

Still no SWP, Kompany, Benjani, Cas to choose from

On the bench we had the likes of Etuhu and Geovanni

I think we should be at least almost as good this season even when we can't use Robinho. We're still in the relegation battle having Robinho in our squad.

15 dec
Final Manchester City 4 - 2 Bolton Wanderers City of Manchester Stadium (40,506

1 Andreas Isaksson (G)
22 Richard Dunne (D)
3 Michael Ball (D)
2 Micah Richards (D)
16 Vedran Corluka (D)
21 Dietmar Hamann (M)
15 Martin Petrov (M)
6 Michael Johnson (M)
28 Fernandes Gelson (M)
12 Darius Vassell (ST)
10 Rolando Bianchi (ST)

22 dec

Final Aston Villa 1 - 1 Manchester City Villa Park (41,455

25 Joe Hart (G)
22 Richard Dunne (D)
3 Michael Ball (D)
4 Nedum Onuoha (D)
2 Micah Richards (D)
21 Dietmar Hamann (M)
15 Martin Petrov (M)
11 Blumer Elano (M)
28 Fernandes Gelson (M)
12 Darius Vassell (ST)
10 Rolando Bianchi (ST)

27 dec
Final Manchester City 2 - 2 Blackburn Rovers City of Manchester Stadium (42,112)

25 Joe Hart (G)
22 Richard Dunne (D)
3 Michael Ball (D)
4 Nedum Onuoha (D)
2 Micah Richards (D)
16 Vedran Corluka (D)
15 Martin Petrov (M)
7 Stephen Ireland (M)
28 Fernandes Gelson (M)
12 Darius Vassell (ST)
10 Rolando Bianchi (ST)

5 points from 3 games. I remember being disappointed with that. Now I'd would have taken that before the WBA game and being relieved.

Remarkable how things have changed so quickly.
 
drc said:
Last year e were'nt really overwhelmed about a ninth place because of our start (we got cocky and wanted more). We had problems with injuries last year too.

The thing about last year was building for this year. We bought many-non english players and players like Elano, Corlika, Garrido, Boj,Petrov etc hopefully would gain experience from one year in the Prem League. Obviously it was too tough to be good a whole year and adding some tumult between the owner and the manager the end was qtuie bad and the 8-1 embarrasing. The Middlesborugh fight was though not too important and I can understand that the players (if they liked the current management) was a bit fed up.

However the squad Hughes inherited, (if Hughes thought that the city squad was shite then he wouldn't hva come) was young players like Ireland, Johnsson, Gelson, Sturridge etc getting better and gaining more experience.

It was Elano, petrov, Corluka, Garrido, Gelson (again), Caceido getting some experience from EPL and hopefully som of them could be better mentally this year.

Add to that, City dreamsigning SWP who was just what we needed a great right-winger, Robinho one of the best players in the world, Jo aproven goalscorer, and some depth in the squad with Zabaleta, Kompany, Ben-Haim. We should be much better this year and would of course fight for a top-6 spot. Just look at the bookies odds before the season.

Of course even if it's Sven, Mark or Stuart who buy players all of them won't come good because of various reasons. Some won't settle, some foreign players are just not cut for EPL but that's not always the easiest thing to know when you buy a quality players, some of ther are just a pure mistake buying but if you buy three and two comes out great and one is a failure I think it's pretty good.

Anyway I think it's really thinking backwards saying we can't compete for a top 6 place. To say that we should be big 4 is too much but we should compete with Everton, Portshmouth and Villa up there.

Excellent post
 
--------------Hart---------------
Corluka---Micah----Dunne---Ball
------Fernandes----Johnson-----
Ireland--------Elano-------Petrov
---------------------Benjani--------------------

Reserves: Vassell, Sturridge, Bojinov, Nedum, Caicedo, Geovanni, Hamann, Garrido, Etuhu...

If someone last season would have told us that Sven would have 70M to strenghten the team with a striker, a dm, a rm, a lb and cb - a team that still managed to be pretty hard do break down and were within a shout of the top six til the very end inspite of Frank's dealings and, oh let's not forget, a defensive line without Micah, Dunne and Nedum and with f-ing Jihai and Elano in it at periods - any f-ing one of us would have taken it. Just imagine our basic game plus SWP, Jo, Kompany, TBH, Zabaleta and Robinho...


I'm all for stability and I've had to bite my toungue, actually agreeing with some of the semi-racist numpties that suggested it was a good idea to let Sven go for a (keyword) british manager, but the man is a complete waste of space. There's no defence for it. It's like someones shat a pile of Barca-strategy into his head without a single clue on what the pragmatics of the game is.

And that's what makes great managers great - pragmatics. They know when to tighten a shit squad to make them hard to break down, and they know when to allow free flow. ALL the great managers do this. And ALL of them, get's slaughtered by idiots who wants "more urgency" or "a less pessimistic approach". And NONE of the critics or their respective coaches of choice... has ever won anything of stature - let alone been able to repeat it.


Hughes is in this regard a special kind of idiot. He's dismantled alot of the support duties (or are simply inept when it comes to having the players do them) and tries to play a offensive game with the signature hoofing "passion/direct football" that only a former striker with minute team responsibily would belive in. The idiot is even so arrogant that he tries to sell his boyish/idiotic non-coaching experience by accusing one of the top 5 most succesful managers in modern history of not knowing how to do his job.

Now let's compare this boyish numpt with a few real managers - Mourinho, Capello, Trapattoni, SGE, Scolari - all travelling men who has managed to repeat their success in a number of clubs in a number of different countries. ALL of which have been both accused of "negative football" at times. ALL with massive success. ALL with a basis in the "eliminate mistakes, determine the game with skills" school of coaching. ALL with teams who have not only played "negative football", but when allowed to develop their defensive game, have also stood for attacking football with plenty of goals in a repeatable, consistent formula. ALL of which have gone for the modern approach of keeping ALL the players happy, eliminating fuzz and running a smooth operation. ALL with their roots in possessional football with mind instead of heart. And then throw Hughes in amongst those managers...



My last straw was when SWP went public to contradict the critisism against Hughes from Elano and Robinho. There's no doubt in my mind that Sparky won't think twice about not giving him a scrubbing for going official with the bickering, cause this is the sort of idiot he is.

We had the same problems with Elano last season which SGE very diplomatically and experienced managed to defuse. We saw Bianchi and Samaras leave with a smile on their faces and without any hard feelings. And he even managed to work out the problem of benching his countryman, a Swedish international, for a much younger and untried goalie without too much of a stir. He managed to avoid the pitfalls.

If you look at Adriano and Mourinho in the Inter-situation, he's doing the exact same thing SGE did when Bianchi cried to the press - he managed those problems internally and the official message was "it's normal for a great player who don't play to be upset. I would be more concerned if he didn't" - almost the exact same reply as SGE gave with Bianchi and that any of the above mentioned coaches would give. And this is f-ing Mourinho we're talking about. *lick, lick* *rub, rub*

Capello - the same with F-ing Beckham... or... Mutu...... or Del Piero (!)...

But this isn't good enough for our Huggy...

Nooo...

Let' set an example with Elano, take it up the ass with Robinho and have SWP lick ass in public (contradicting the former two). In fact - let's have the f-ing press with Martin F-ing Shitphony run the team while we're at it. We could have a Big Brother style voting booth and send the f-ers off one by one.

It is beyond poor management. It's f-ing retarded. It's Baconface without the weight of a succesful club with asshole traditions in place and a totalitary regime to back it up. No scottish asshole charm either. It's a cocky hooligan with a bat and a bunch of "mates". "Lord of The Flies" or "Eden Lake". "Piiiggy, Piiiggy..."

This numpt will NEVER manage to get a team with the sort of egos involved in world class players within a hierarchy to function. Nor will he ever manage anything or anyone who wont sign on to his terms and attitude (hardworking mediocrity with shitty United gang rape-attitude)... and I find it extremly hard to think that he's the one to get a Romario, Maradona, Stoichkov, Ronaldo, Batistuta, Pele, Ronaldinho... Cantona... or any other of the disgustingly egomaniac sob:s who have graced football with their skills... to actually work with the work horses who have allowed them to flourish, in a atmosphere that still says "team". Instead he breeds mediocrity. The notion that all of them should be treated equally (at least on the surface. I'd love to see him go up against Robinho) and ALL players should have "passion" as a trait, instead of a required and specialised skill.

And that's as stupid as telling Kompany to "kick it like Robinho"... or throwing Cambiasso off the team just cause he doesn't have the closing qualities of Ibrahimovic.

God bless those that have both though. Really. I'm sure one day someone will come along and embody both Matthäus and Maradona. He probably wont cope very well with the hierarchy though, cause he'd probably be annoyed as f**k with players not working hard enough nor having the sort of technical skill sets he himself had. In fact - he'd probably be on a constant head rant when things weren't going that well. "Those f-ers! Can't run, can't pass, can't shoot... Where's my tennis racket?!"


And this is without even pointing at his team selection and his complete inability to change a game with substitutions and speaking strictly in terms of actual managerial qualities... And the buys... I hope there isn't a manager that wouldn't consider buying Kompany, Zabaleta, TBH, SWP, Jo and Robinho - five of which are important figures in their national teams...



So yes, of course we should be in the top six with any half decent manager. We stayed within sixth most of last season with f-ing Jihai Sun and a whole range of problems working against our favour. There isn't a single doubt in my mind that we wouldn't have improved on the results if Sven had been allowed to continue his project - and our team effort and tactics... let's just say there was a time when we made actual progress instead of going backwards. When there was an actual comprehendable thought behind our overall strategy instead of refermenting old ideas, branding them as ones own and failing utterly when trying to incorporate anything new in what was already there, in a totally random, amateuristic fashion...

The only way we could get within sixth at the moment is to let Hughes buy his mediocrity. And we are better than that. It'd be like spending money on a Volvo for safety when we've alredy got a fairly safe and fast Subaru, when the issue really isn't the car but the obviously alcoholic driver. A team with so many leading internationals (even the supposed shitty young ones Sven bought, all considered their respective countries future and thus almost guaranteed a great learning curve)... there's no way we should settle for less than sixth.

Or at least not in this way. Not without some actual sign of progress, management, tactical nous or ability to change the games.

Failing graciously is ok - incompetence, shit facedness and sheer stupidity... is not.


*rant over*
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.