Bit confused there as u say he doesnt create ...but then admit he is 'composed on the ball' and 'can pick out a decent pass'....
I do like Noble,a damn good player..but maybe his own skills were not enough to drive WHU to any success....perhaps thats why they took a chance on Wilshire....ive always thought wilshere lookeda tidy composed central midfield player...whose main attributes appeared to be moving the ball in a tidy fashion from derp central mid up to attacking areas..his ball retention/control was very good..plays a bit like our Gundogan...you need players like this in a passing team to form a cohesive link between defence and attack.Wilshere would always show for the ball and be comfortable on if...his dribbling skills in tight situations were also top notch iirc...I would have been quite happy if he,d signed for City a few years back.
As you say his injuries have become all to predictable now-but thats not his fault surely?
Just out of interest BH.. was it Manuel who signed the player ,or did he arrive before the manager?