What City player was most over rated by our own fans

[Skashion]

Clichy.

 

[meeesh]

Im going with Richard Dunne! I never liked him tbh

4 years on the trot player of the year.......................................................................like him or not he was immense at times,and shit as well I grant you,but never liked him ??? mmmmmmmmmm the mind boggles

Dunne winning player of the year 4 times in a row shows how bad City were not how good Dunne was in my opinion and i just didn't like him he was slow and error prone. Distin and Wiekens were both better

Stop talking out of your fanny,the guy also has represented his country over 70 times as well,your thread title doesn't back up your comments,why did you not just put "the city players you didn't like"

 

[kippaxchris]

4 years on the trot player of the year.......................................................................like him or not he was immense at times,and shit as well I grant you,but never liked him ??? mmmmmmmmmm the mind boggles

Dunne winning player of the year 4 times in a row shows how bad City were not how good Dunne was in my opinion and i just didn't like him he was slow and error prone. Distin and Wiekens were both better

Stop talking out of your fanny,the guy also has represented his country over 70 times as well,your thread title doesn't back up your comments,why did you not just put "the city players you didn't like"

I didn't like him as he was slow and error prone so i think he is and was over rated so my comments fully back up the thread title as they are footballing reasons and he was highly rated by most

 

[Cellarite]

Benjani (although his debut goal explains a lot of it), Andy fucking Dibble and Craig Bellamy.

 

[gordondaviesmoustache]

As much as I love him I have to say The Goat, I'm afraid.

 

[Dogtanian]

Kinkladze, there you go i said it!

Have you got a spare flak jacket with you, and I'll join you!

Jim if it kicks off i'm telling the mods :)

 

[Cellarite]

As much as I love him I have to say The Goat, I'm afraid.

Despite over 100 goals?

 

[mancitymick]

Kinkladze - Never bought into the w@nk fest

 

[gordondaviesmoustache]

As much as I love him I have to say The Goat, I'm afraid.

Despite over 100 goals?

Of course, as that is an undeniable fact, or at least 84 is ;-)

When we've signed some top European strikers in the last few years I've heard and read supporters use Goater as a benchmark for them.

This is a guy we signed from Bristol City (when he was approaching his peak) and sold to Reading. I love him, love the way he stuck at it after a lot of abuse and he scored some truly memorable goals (Wigan play off semi; Blackburn promotion; last Maine Road Derby x2) but he was a fairly limited player who scored 13 Premier League goals in two seasons.

It says a lot about our club and its supporters that he remains a legend to this day as it shows we haven't forgotten where we've come from, but as a player he is vastly overrated by many City fans.

 

[mancitymick]

As much as I love him I have to say The Goat, I'm afraid.

Despite over 100 goals?

Of course, as that is an undeniable fact.

When we've signed some top European strikers in the last few years I've heard and read supporters use Goater as a benchmark for them.

This is a guy we signed from Bristol City (when he was approaching his peak) and sold to Southend. I love him, love the way he stuck at it after a lot of abuse and he scored some truly memorable goals (Wigan play off semi; Blackburn promotion; last Maine Road Derby x2) but he was a fairly limited player who scored 13 Premier League goals in two seasons.

It says a lot about our club and its supporters that he remains a legend to this day as it shows we haven't forgotten where we've come from, but as a player he is vastly overrated by many City fans.

Was it not Reading wee sold him to?