what's your pro-Hughes rating?

[bluemanc]

Do a list of the clubs Hughes has managed. Do a list of the clubs Mourinho has managed. Compare the 2 lists. SImple reply to a very silly comment.

silly reply to simple comment more like.

why do you think Jose got the jobs he has had?

He isn't our manager so even though he may be your fav football manager this week it's not going to change anything.
I take it now Hiddinks been ridiculed & outed as a busted flush jose has taken his place.

 

[jeffmr2]

I'd score him 35% he gets 25% bonus for being welsh :)

 

[moomba]

I take it now Hiddinks been ridiculed & outed as a busted flush jose has taken his place.

Hiddink a busted flush?

I've heard it all now.

 

[jake28]

All I know is, if Hughes was an unknown foreigner 90% of fans would be calling for his head.

 

[cleavers]

40 %, I hope he sorts it out, but doubt he will, and by the time we realise he hasn't it will be 2 wasted years and a shed load of money.

I didn't rate him before he came, I expected huff and puff and long ball, and he's done little to change that so far, I hope he does (soon).

 

[alera]

55%....I was a believer and stuck with him but he continues to make terrible tactical mistakes...

For me and probably with the owners he has until the end of the season. Its obvious to everyone that after the money that has been spent, if he doesnt come up with the goods he is screwed come the end of the season.

At which stage we will get in Hiddink or Special one and spaff another £100 million minimum on players.

 

[Dobsy87]

73%

He MUST finish fourth this season or he is for the chop (Dobsy knows . . .)

 

[Tez Tosterone]

Man-management 40%

Transfer activity - 68.75% .. based on the undermentioned signings, I've excluded Robinho and Jo as he was given them as a fait accompli

Roque Santa Cruz 20%
Carlos Tevez ......75%
Gareth Barry........80%
Nigel de Jong.......85%
Emm Adebayor..... 65%
Shay Given........ 100%
Wayne Bridge......50%
Kolo Toure.......... 70%
Joleon Lescott...... 70%
Vincent Kompany.. 55%
Craig Bellamy....... 80%
Shaun Wright Phillips 75%

Handling Media/Press Conferences 50%

Motivational Skills - 35% (that may be on the generous side, to put it mildly)

Tactical Strategy incl. formations/Team Selection/Tactical Substitutions - 40%

SO, AVERAGED OUT FROM IT's 46.80%

I'd imagine that Hiddink, Mourinho, Ferguson, Pelligrini and Wenger would all be in the 80% area. At least.

 

[levets]

Man-management 40%

Transfer activity - 68.75% .. based on the undermentioned signings, I've excluded Robinho and Jo as he was given them as a fait accompli

Roque Santa Cruz 20%
Carlos Tevez ......75%
Gareth Barry........80%
Nigel de Jong.......85%
Emm Adebayor..... 65%
Shay Given........ 100%
Wayne Bridge......50%
Kolo Toure.......... 70%
Joleon Lescott...... 70%
Vincent Kompany.. 55%
Craig Bellamy....... 80%
Shaun Wright Phillips 75%

Handling Media/Press Conferences 50%

Motivational Skills - 35% (that may be on the generous side, to put it mildly)

Tactical Strategy incl. formations/Team Selection/Tactical Substitutions - 40%

SO, AVERAGED OUT FROM IT's 46.80%

I'd imagine that Hiddink, Mourinho, Ferguson, Pelligrini and Wenger would all be in the 80% area. At least.

I think his handling of the media/press conferences is far higher... around 80%


And when his 'tactics' board V Arsenal was shown on here... everybody was creaming themselves and saying how good it was. I find it amazing that people can criticise areas that we have no idea about....

 

[DTeacher]

Do me a favour. Make a list of all Mourinho's trophies. Make a list of all Hughes's trophies. Compare the two lists.

Do a list of the clubs Hughes has managed. Do a list of the clubs Mourinho has managed. Compare the 2 lists. SImple reply to a very silly comment.

Even though I am more Hughes 'IN' than Hughes 'OUT', that is ridiculously condescending, not to mention misguided and WRONG! It wasn't his answer that was silly, it was yours!

I also cannot remember PORTO being a World power?

Anyway, why exactly do all these 'big' Clubs appoint Jose? (That seems to be your stance - only 'big' clubs appoint Jose, so success is easier, so your warped thinking suggests?)