Which moments from our history would you want to retrospectively check using VAR?

[deedee]

Alf Grey in the LC Semi in 81. We would have done the dippers that night if we had scored in the first minute

 

[jimharri]

Who was it who got carded for aggressive walking? That would need to be replayed on VAR to see if it was really justified.

"Super" Kevin Horlock.

 

[SteveP]

Goater v Wigan in the play off semi before Gillingham ……. maybe not haha

 

[jimharri]

Goater v Wigan in the play off semi before Gillingham ……. maybe not haha

Still not sure about that goal. If it was down the other end, we'd have been screaming for handball.

 

[kinky's boots]

is that not self explanatory?
i read the topic, i posted my view, i could care less about dwelling on it.

 

[Scottyboi]

Yes, the one where their guy shoulder barged him and fell over or something.

Barged him and won a penalty I was at the game and I was disgusted.



1 minute in

 

[East Level 2]

Alan Ball's appointment, there was definitely something foul about that.

Almost as fishy (but much more damaging) as some of the players we purchased when KK was in charge.

 

[sheepskin_tearaway]

The first leg of that tie there were numerous offside calls that looked dodgy, plus the usual Robertson foul on Sterling in the penalty area.

The game was bent. End of.

 

[91:23]

December 2011: John Terry's foul on David Silva when City were winning 1-0, (in the days when we never missed penalties).
City go 2-0 up and we cruise the Premier League rather than losing all our momentum, and having to rely on the last second of the last game.

However, for the sake of balance, I don't think Paul Lake's last minute scrambled effort at Blackpool would have survived a VAR review

Similarly Rotherham might cite a certain Christian Negouai for his hand of God.

Or the Goats goal v Wigan in play off semi. since said he handled it I believe

 

[80s Shorts]

It should've been 10.