Who are the good pundits?

[idahoblues]

Rag!





































Pien Meulensteen Think she’s a Rag! ;)

View attachment 52778

Oh
Yes

 

[SamTheGuru]

I quite like Neville. Souness is very good too,

 

[Barcon]

Paul Scholes helps my insomnia and I'm sure Utd currently cause his .

It’ll be the balls slamming up against his chin that keeps him awake soon enough

 

[SamTheGuru]

I have to say that I find Richards an embarrassment when it comes to analysis.

 

[southamptonblue]

Jobi McAnuff




.......yep, that's the full list I can listen to, all the rest are 'put the kettle on' time.

 

[bluemonkey71]

Souness

 

[Barcon]

It’ll be the balls slamming up against his chin that keeps him awake soon enough

Oops, wrong rag.

 

[GX Blue]

Gary Neville for City. Yep, that’s Gary Neville.
When he speaks about us it’s usually always on the money.

 

[the talisman]

Had a female commentator for yesterdays match who was pretty good and a sharp contrast to her sidekick, Stephen Warnock, who couldn't keep his fucking trap shut.

A special mention for Warnock for the stupidest comment of the season so far. Haaland headed away a Bournemouth corner
“That’s exactly what he’s in the team for”
Yes, Stephen, we bought the most sought after young striker in the world just so that we could put him on the near post for Bournemouth’s only corner.

 

[cjn]

The insidious creep of anonymous ill informed female pundits has led me to revise my opinion of male pundits I previously found to be irritating.

The likes of Carragher and Redknapp on Sky or Wright and Dublin on the bbc might have their shortcomings as pundits but they are familiar faces who I enjoyed watching play the game and have developed into characters who can hold a conversation.

I don’t think the broadcasters understand what the fans want from punditry. We don’t need analysis or technical insight, the vast majority of fans understand the nuances of the game perfectly well. What we want are familiar faces who we know have played at a high level in games we remember watching, discussing what’s happened.

Foisting upon us women we’ve never heard of to trot out cliche after cliche without adding anything to the conversation ticks a box but alienates many viewers

This is a terrible take. Your criteria leads to the status quo of ex Liverpool and United players sarcastically calling our games. I'd prefer a totally anonymous knowledgeable person who's actually trained in broadcasting, male or female.