Who's More Important ?

[raghunter57]

KUN..............

..............................................and soon his mate.

 

[ManuelPellegrini]

Kompany or Aguero ?

Pantillimon

 

[pee dubya]

In general it depends on the opposition. Against weaker teams, Aguero. Against stronger teams, Komps.

I think it's the opposite, Aguero is the striker we have that can produce a goal from nothing, the real top top quality player you need to score against the very best. Against weaker opposition our other strikers are more than capable of scoring the goals rquired.

We need Kompany, for the bigger games also, but for consistency. A shaky defence is shaky against any team in the league, without Kompany we're much more likely to drop points against weaker teams than we are without Aguero.

 

[ctidcarl]

I do not care if we concede 9. As long as we score 10. Therefore, Sergio. However, scoring 10 is unlikely and so is conceding 9 unless appalling defence which even without Kompany isn't appalling. I say Sergio on that argument

Within the next two seasons, we will score ten in a match, I'm really confident of this

And back on topic - Vinnie (and I love Sergio!!) but Vinnie is the more important as he's the biggest loss when he doesn't play and he's our captain

 

[Wretched Vengeance]

Currently Sergio. We are having to learn to live without Vince. I'd rather De michelis Nastasic over Dzeko Negredo

 

[Blue Haze]

The way Joe is playing, Pantilimon.

 

[fablue]

The way Joe is playing, Pantilimon.

Richard Wright!

 

[DiscoSteve]

demichelis is 'just about' covering for Vinny - no-one else comes close.

So I vote Sergio as more important

 

[citytill1die84]

Kompany because I still feel Dzeko and Negredo would chalk up enough goals to win the games we've won.

 

[MaxCityBlue]

Kompany for me. Firstly because he's a world class player and secondly he brings a stability and confidence to our back four (not to mention our keeper) that no other player can. That said, Kun is awesome and is currently on fire! Long may it continue.