Didsbury Dave
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 1 Feb 2007
- Messages
- 38,032
Lancet Fluke said:Didsbury Dave said:Lancet Fluke said:I don't really understand why we would have told him he can leave. He's definitely going in the summer with his contract running out but regardless of his limitations, he knows the league, he has a long standing and pretty reliable partnership with Kompany, he's done a decent job when called upon and we have so many games coming up we will need our whole sqaud to contribute. Why take the risk of replacing him with someone who may not have played in the prem before and will not have established any kind of partnership with our number one centre back. Makes little sense to me going into a title run in.
I don't know the details at all, lancet, but I'd imagine he wants first team football every week and has requested a move. He gave the game away in an interview after a recent game where he was non-committal, sort of "we'll have to see what happens". I'm guessing that given that, city are shopping around for a world class centre half. I doubt any are available though, so I'm sure he will stay.
That's why summer makes sense, then we will be able to get a proper long term replacement. It's just an unnecessary piece of business imo if we do it. he's on excellent money, just tell him he's staying. He will get a reasonable amount of games and will have a good chance of winning some medals. He won't get in the England squad imo whether he moves or not. Hodgson loves some of those shite united defenders like smalling and jones.
I suspect that's more or less how it is: that city have said 'you're not going anywhere unless we sign a replacement'. But they sure as shit won't be looking at a demichelis type replacement. It will be top drawer players. The point I'm trying to make is that city will be in ongoing dialogue with agents about their players, and I'd be very surprised if centre half wasn't a priority. On the off chance they can make one of those deals happen now he might be allowed to go.
Otherwise, as you say, summer is ideal for us. I take your point about it being ideal for him too but I'd guess he won't have ruled Brazil out.
What's better for a player? 20 starts for Stoke in a relegation scrap and a chance of Brazil, or 8 starts for us and a couple of medals but no World Cup? I don't know.