Second Skin said:
For me it was Mark Lillis in the FA Cup against Coventry some time in the mid 80s. The game was being shown live on TV and I think it ended 1-1 and we got stuffed in the replay.
I still haven't forgiven him for that.
The game was against Watford. It wasn't live on TV either. :)
The worst missed penalty was definitely Alan Harper against Leeds in 1990. It nearly hit the roof of the North Stand.
The worst penalty actually went in. Steve Redmond away to West Ham. Fell flat on his back side, spooned it down the middle and it somehow bounced in.