RoqueSantaBoozeCruz said:
Monkeys first album good but now gash.
Oasis never lived up to their early promise.
Stone Roses have one album which is incredibly overrated and a shit one.
Agreed re Arctic Monkeys, decent first album even if it was just The Libertines with a less witty Jarvis Cocker fronting them.
Oasis, never reached the same commercial heights but they've done some really good tunes since the first 2 albums, just perhaps not a cohesive classic album to rival Definitely Maybe.
Stone Roses - Debut was 10/10 perfect, also the tunes from that era that weren't on the album (Somethings Burnings/Fools Gold/Where Angels Play/Standing here etc) are all classics, they were perfect around that time. I really like The Second Coming too, obviously it is nowhere near as good as the debut but it has it's moments.