They cut far too much for you to get a real sense of the game, and sometimes miss out what I would consider key moments. I don't really value their pundits views either, for every good comment there are several bad or lazy ones. It surely is hard to give balanced, but entertaining, impartial views but sometimes, whether it be the pundits or the highlight planners, they seem to not even try.
I sometimes catch it on a Sunday morning if the baby has me out of bed early, otherwise it was deleted from our Sky planner long ago. I think that the future of football highlights is only going one way - full matches on playback where you will eventually be able to play a choice of the full match, only goals, shots on goal, key moments, after-match comments and discussions etc etc, and for that Sky is in prime position and the BBC is far, far behind.
Incredible though to think that the BBC may be dropping it completely, given the interest and money associated with football in this century.
I did feel like their recent live from Salford Boys' Club, whilst great to see them there, smacked of someone changing things and trying something new out of sheer desperation, and not to show off their new locality as was reported.