Surely agree it's better than not having him? We loan him and could still potentially sign him at the end of the season. From Paddy's interview yesterday we tried to sign him permanently but City didn't want to sell or loan him to us. “Celtic did try to get the move permanent but in fairness to City they wanted to keep me and said that couldn’t happen. It gives me a bit of hope, obviously, that they still feel I have a long-term future which is good for me. Talking to them I said I felt it was in my best interests to come back to Celtic. Luckily enough they listened to me and took it on board. I was just thinking about my own development and where I felt I would improve." Good move for the kid, suits everyone involved.