Err because he got injured. I know he's a good player. But is he good enough to play in a team that will be trying to win the Premier League. We thought Bravo was good enough. Maybe he is. Man Utd and most City fans thought Pogba was not only good enough, but the best midfielder on the planet, turned out he was distinctly average. So unless he proves himself on the pitch in a City shirt we don't know do we. He's played 9 league games for City. That's not enough.
I'm not having that. Gundogan is world-class. At least the level of KDB. And he proved it as well, time and time again at Dortmund. The man scored two goals against Barcelona for us. The fact that you haven't seen him play well for years doesn't mean he hasn't.