Disagree some of the fans started getting on his back and that turns the managers hand.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Stefan Savic - Atletico Madrid
- Thread starter Bilboblue
- Start date
Bilboblue
Well-Known Member
Disagree some of the fans started getting on his back and that turns the managers hand.
Again, that's bollocks, with all due respect.
Then why did we let a player go who is now signing for last years Champions League finalists ?Again, that's bollocks, with all due respect.
jimharri
Moderator
Because he wasn't good enough for us. Repeat, in case you missed it; for us. Just because a player goes on and plays for a good team in the future, does not necessarily mean we made a mistake with him. Boateng was another one who couldn't hack it in the PL. And Nastasic may well turn out to be another one. City can only go by what they see in the player while he's at the club, not how he may turn out in 5 years' time.Then why did we let a player go who is now signing for last years Champions League finalists ?
Bilboblue
Well-Known Member
Then why did we let a player go who is now signing for last years Champions League finalists ?
Remind me which club he signed for when he left us?
You are trying, and failing to justify your train of thought on this player.
Scaring Europe to Death
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 31 Oct 2014
- Messages
- 3,937
Because he wasn't good enough for us. Repeat, in case you missed it; for us. Just because a player goes on and plays for a good team in the future, does not necessarily mean we made a mistake with him. Boateng was another one who couldn't hack it in the PL. And Nastasic may well turn out to be another one. City can only go by what they see in the player while he's at the club, not how he may turn out in 5 years' time.
I watch a lot of German football, and I can't ever remember being so underwhelmed, as I was by Boateng's brief period at the ETIHAD.
Top defender for Hamburg and Germany, but as soon as he dons a City shirt, outpaced by Charlie Adams.
So people are genuinely suggesting we should have kept him? He wasn't good enough, he might not even be good enough now. It's the same as the people claiming we should have kept Trippier, they are only at the level they are now because they played 50 games a year for a couple of years getting better at a lower level, which we could never afford to give them, as they weren't remotely good enough. Good on them for going down a level (or two) and making a career for themselves, but we were completely correct to let them go.
jimharri
Moderator
I don't have the slightest doubt that he's a very good player in the Bundesliga. But he wasn't cut out for the faster, more "in your face" type of play that he was up against in the PL. The same could be said for Veron when he was at the shitpit. He didn't suddenly become a bad player overnight.I watch a lot of German football, and I can't ever remember being so underwhelmed, as I was by Boateng's brief period at the ETIHAD.
Top defender for Hamburg and Germany, but as soon as he dons a City shirt, outpaced by Charlie Adams.
I wish him all the best but just because he's moved on to a club as good as Atletico doesn't mean we should regret selling.
He was much improved at Fiorentina, which earned him this move, but who is to say he's good enough for AM? Maybe a Europa League side is where he excels best.
Again, I wish him all the best. Just saying.
He was much improved at Fiorentina, which earned him this move, but who is to say he's good enough for AM? Maybe a Europa League side is where he excels best.
Again, I wish him all the best. Just saying.