Referees/Officials 2017/18 performances

Status
Not open for further replies.
Did well however how the fuck he didn't give that decision when Leroy got flattened from behind is a fucking mystery.
 
Four games in and only the Brighton match hasn't centred on a referee decision. I always look forward to every game, but nowadays with an extra sense of trepidation.
 
Rammy Blue said:
Did well however how the fuck he didn't give that decision when Leroy got flattened from behind is a fucking mystery.
Click to expand...
Probably getting his breath back !

running-end.gif
 
moon said:
First goal had a little help from lino and ref error
Ederson took free kick for offside and lino flagged because it didn't go out of the box
Retaken and Aguero scored from the move
Click to expand...

I was asking my son about that, I couldn't believe the lino had been so stupid and convinced myself it was for something else, at least you have cleared it up and i was right.
 
richardtheref said:
Have just received an invite to attend a refs meeting where the one & only Anthony Taylor will be in attendance. Any questions you Bluemooners would like me to ask the great man.
Click to expand...

Why, in the melee that followed Kun's 'tackle' were only City players sent off. Why did you not send off the big guy who shoved Aguero over onto the floor. How did you manage to arrive at the conclusion that that was not violent play? Ok, OK, that's two questions but it is The Alty Tit! I'm in Graham Poll mode - that's three questions when I thought it was only two!
 
moon said:
First goal had a little help from lino and ref error
Ederson took free kick for offside and lino flagged because it didn't go out of the box
Retaken and Aguero scored from the move
Click to expand...

Actually they got it right. Under Law 13: the ball
  • is in play when it is kicked and clearly moves except for a free kick to the defending team in their penalty area where the ball is in play when it is kicked directly out of the penalty area
 
Bert Trautmann's Parachute said:
This is what a game looks like when we get properly reffed.
Click to expand...

Some of the refs get some of their decisions right some of the time. I think Jonny got most of his season's decisions right yesterday. I hope to fuck we don't get him back this season as I fear he will be all over the show, and that's not implying his physical presence will be all over the pitch!
 
Norbiton said:
Actually they got it right. Under Law 13: the ball
  • is in play when it is kicked and clearly moves except for a free kick to the defending team in their penalty area where the ball is in play when it is kicked directly out of the penalty area
Click to expand...

Oh right !! fuck me, thanks for clearing that up.
 
There were two free kicks I side the defending penalty area yesterday which had to be retaken for what looked like the ball did not clear the penalty area. I thoght this rule was just for dead balls or were they retaken for another reason?
 
manchester blue said:
There were two free kicks I side the defending penalty area yesterday which had to be retaken for what looked like the ball did not clear the penalty area. I thoght this rule was just for dead balls or were they retaken for another reason?
Click to expand...
IIRC, one of them was retaken because the ball was moving.
 
He's being severely disciplined by PiGMOL.​

He failed to send off Ederson instead for simulation.
 
manchester blue said:
There were two free kicks I side the defending penalty area yesterday which had to be retaken for what looked like the ball did not clear the penalty area. I thoght this rule was just for dead balls or were they retaken for another reason?
Click to expand...

It's the same for goal kicks and free kicks, though I'm not sure what the logic is in requiring a free kick to clear the area.
 
cleavers said:
I must be in a minority, because I thought he got quite a few decisions wrong on both sides, and bottled a couple, but from our point, that is the best we are likely to get.

Got the biggest decision spot on, and it changed the course of the game for us.
Click to expand...
You are not alone

Typical that an undisputable red card for the other team results in so much of a sudden view that city are fairly treated

And just look at the reaction of the shite pundits regarding that sending off - absolute clarity on how biased they are against City
 
Last edited:
Norbiton said:
It's the same for goal kicks and free kicks, though I'm not sure what the logic is in requiring a free kick to clear the area.
Click to expand...

Thank you. I'm not either! If anything it puts the team that had the advantage at a disadvantage as, if the opponents mark up, it means the keeper has to go long where it's 50-50 who wins possession. There's sillier rules I guess.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top