A letter on justice and open debate.

[JRockBlues]

Why?

Maybe something to do with her recent travails on transphobia.

 

[Ban-jani]

Maybe something to do with her recent travails on transphobia.

Behave yourself.

She responded to someone saying “people who menstruate” with “we used to call them women”.

How the fuck is that transphobic?

She’s also questioned the rushing of young people into hormone therapy without analysing their mental condition more specifically.

The world has gone fucking bonkers if JK Rowing is now considered a bigot.

When the left think their own are Nazis it’s no wonder they behave like they do towards everyone else.

Fucking lunatics.

 

[Ban-jani]

Why?

Because he’s a radical left wing ideologue, so everyone to the right of Ed Miliband is a Nazi.

 

[JRockBlues]

Because he’s a radical left wing ideologue, so everyone to the right of Ed Miliband is a Nazi.

Woohoo! I've been radicalised!

 

[Ban-jani]

Woohoo! I've been radicalised!

No comment on why JK Rowling is now transphobic?

Thought not.

 

[mexico1970]

No comment on why JK Rowling is now transphobic?

Thought not.

Germaine Greer has had the same treatment, she's gone from being a front runner in the feminist 2nd wave to a pariah because of her views on the effect trans women have on feminist issues. She has been de-platformed and labelled transphobic because she stated biological truths.

In 20 or so years time trans activists will be the new pariahs for eating meat or not agreeing that Fish are humans too.

 

[JRockBlues]

No comment on why JK Rowling is now transphobic?

Thought not.

Well I never actually called her a transphobe. I just intimated she'd had some problems after something she said on the subject. But because I've dared to challenge you on a couple of topics I'm now branded as a radical left wing idealogue. That's nice.

 

[Mazzarelli's Swiss Cheese]

Germaine Greer has had the same treatment, she's gone from being a front runner in the feminist 2nd wave to a pariah because of her views on the effect trans women have on feminist issues. She has been de-platformed and labelled transphobic because she stated biological truths.

In 20 or so years time trans activists will be the new pariahs for eating meat or not agreeing that Fish are humans too.

I must admit to a little schadenfreude at Ms Greer , once the darling of the liberal PC brigade now falling foul of the next generation.

 

[Ban-jani]

Well I never actually called her a transphobe. I just intimated she'd had some problems after something she said on the subject. But because I've dared to challenge you on a couple of topics I'm now branded as a radical left wing idealogue. That's nice.

You know full when you were highlighting her “transphobia”.

The people calling her that are absolute fuckwits, I wouldn’t align with them mate.

 

[JRockBlues]

You know full when you were highlighting her “transphobia”.

The people calling her that are absolute fuckwits, I wouldn’t align with them mate.

Having not stated my personal views of whether or not JK Rowling is a transphobe I am therefore not aligning with anyone. To be clear, I tend to try and avoid aligning with nutjobs on most subjects. But as this thread is neither about transphobia or JK Rowling's views I think we should conclude this particular discussion and let this thread continue on its original purpose or die a natural death.

 

[Ban-jani]

Having not stated my personal views of whether or not JK Rowling is a transphobe I am therefore not aligning with anyone. To be clear, I tend to try and avoid aligning with nutjobs on most subjects. But as this thread is neither about transphobia or JK Rowling's views I think we should conclude this particular discussion and let this thread continue on its original purpose or die a natural death.

You did mean that but yes I’m happy to leave it there.

 

[Dax777]

Behave yourself.

She responded to someone saying “people who menstruate” with “we used to call them women”.

How the fuck is that transphobic?

She’s also questioned the rushing of young people into hormone therapy without analysing their mental condition more specifically.

The world has gone fucking bonkers if JK Rowing is now considered a bigot.

When the left think their own are Nazis it’s no wonder they behave like they do towards everyone else.

Fucking lunatics.

Thanks

 

[Dax777]

I must admit to a little schadenfreude at Ms Greer , once the darling of the liberal PC brigade now falling foul of the next generation.

How they don't see this predictable outcome continues to boggle.

I tell my Lady this all the time. Today you are the victim, tomorrow you'd be the oppressor. How can't you see this?

 

[Rascal]

In 2020 you can be described as a hate figure for merely saying that men and women have differences.

In 2020 if you don’t think Britain is institutionally racist you’re a white supremacist Nazi.

In 2020 if you value the family unit you’re a misogynist.

In 2020 if you don’t call people by made up pronouns like “ze” or “zer” you’re a transphobe.

In 2020 if you want to express conservative views at an event, people in masks will show up and beat you and you better well call them anti fascists, because that’s how they describe themselves.

In 2020 if you want to refer to biological females as “women”, you’re a hate figure.

The right has always had people intolerant on its fringes but the left has now joined them and then some.

And you wonder why I say you are going down rabbit holes.

What next, flying the cross of St George is illegal.

 

[Rascal]

If you dare to disagree with the core ideals of the Black Lives Matter organisation, you don’t think that black lives matter and you’re a racist.

If you do agree you are you a Marxist.

Its a bit strange aint it that the explosion of these culture wars just happened to coincide with 50,000+ deaths in the UK. You might almost think its a classic deflection tactic to take away the spotlight from those that are guilty of gross negligence, if they can get people talking about cultural stuff that blames the left for intolerance then who do you think gets away scot free from all charges of stupidity?

Change the narrative, get the Plebians talking about trans rights when in reality its a fringe issue that few have any real interest in, but make out its a major issue, use words like "woke" "sjw" "virtue signaller" "cultural Marxism" and blame the left for it. When in reality those on the left don't identify with these issues, it concentrates on class whilst the issues are a liberal versus illiberal issue. But seeing as most people nowadays seem to think the left is liberal its not difficult to see how it works. The left is not liberal it is definitely more authoritarian, respects all the values its supposed to rail against. See we are not America we don't have liberals and Conservatives, we have Socialists, Liberals and Conservatives and Socialists care about class not the fringe issues like we are accused of caring about.

The irony is that the use of these stories and this narrative actually closes the left out of the debate, we are prejudged and people automatically assume now that we on the left will care about whether somebody has a dick or not, me prsonally i couldnt give a fuck, what i care about is if they are working class they will have more in common with me than with the capitalist class who seek to exploit these divisons.

 

[The perfect fumble]

Change the narrative, get the Plebians talking about trans rights when in reality its a fringe issue that few have any real interest in

That's because it concerns women. You're treading the well worn path of left wing misogyny mate, where women's rights have always been subsumed to masculine class based politics.

The irony is that the use of these stories and this narrative actually closes the left out of the debate, we are prejudged and people automatically assume now that we on the left will care about whether somebody has a dick or not, me prsonally i couldnt give a fuck

Of course you don't, you're a bloke, it doesn't concern you.

Though that stance doesn't exactly chime with this....

The left is not liberal it is definitely more authoritarian, respects all the values its supposed to rail against.

Then stand up for women.

 

[Ban-jani]

And you wonder why I say you are going down rabbit holes.

What next, flying the cross of St George is illegal.

Your posts don’t mean anything.

Just the ramblings of a tired old trot who knows he’s lost the political race.

 

[BobKowalski]

How they don't see this predictable outcome continues to boggle.

I tell my Lady this all the time. Today you are the victim, tomorrow you'd be the oppressor. How can't you see this?

I’m sure your Lady is grateful for you telling her. Although aren’t you just telling her she must remain the victim? Isn’t this just what this railing against BLM is all about? That they ‘should know their place’?

 

[Ban-jani]

If you do agree you are you a Marxist.

Its a bit strange aint it that the explosion of these culture wars just happened to coincide with 50,000+ deaths in the UK. You might almost think its a classic deflection tactic to take away the spotlight from those that are guilty of gross negligence, if they can get people talking about cultural stuff that blames the left for intolerance then who do you think gets away scot free from all charges of stupidity?

Change the narrative, get the Plebians talking about trans rights when in reality its a fringe issue that few have any real interest in, but make out its a major issue, use words like "woke" "sjw" "virtue signaller" "cultural Marxism" and blame the left for it. When in reality those on the left don't identify with these issues, it concentrates on class whilst the issues are a liberal versus illiberal issue. But seeing as most people nowadays seem to think the left is liberal its not difficult to see how it works. The left is not liberal it is definitely more authoritarian, respects all the values its supposed to rail against. See we are not America we don't have liberals and Conservatives, we have Socialists, Liberals and Conservatives and Socialists care about class not the fringe issues like we are accused of caring about.

The irony is that the use of these stories and this narrative actually closes the left out of the debate, we are prejudged and people automatically assume now that we on the left will care about whether somebody has a dick or not, me prsonally i couldnt give a fuck, what i care about is if they are working class they will have more in common with me than with the capitalist class who seek to exploit these divisons.

Tell that to the Labour Party of the last decade.

Hello my name is Jeremy Corbyn and my pronouns are he and him

 

[Ancient Citizen]

'My pronouns are he and him.'
Dearie fucking me.