It's Quiet 17 - Glory Thread

His passing isn’t an issue, mistakes are the issue. His accuracy with the ball has always been 80-90% since he joined the CFG. Conceeding unnecessarily is an issue. No problem with him as a backup if he wants more game time though no problem with that either. I’m sure we’ll find a stopgap. Trafford probably, bazunu will be loaned out again or sold depending on the contract renewal.
 


I haven't seen this posted anywhere so here goes. The reason I see Steffen leaving is it appears as of two days ago he is still in a relationship with Janine Beckie who left City recently to play for the Portland Thorns in the U.S.

Zach just signed an extension to 2025 five months ago in Nov, but I would guess he'd want to follow her back to the U.S. as well. Specifically to the Portland Timbers MLS side.

I have no other info on this other than Beckie left and you'd think he'd be joining her this summer. Unless she's on some very short term deal with the Thorns.
 


I haven't seen this posted anywhere so here goes. The reason I see Steffen leaving is it appears as of two days ago he is still in a relationship with Janine Beckie who left City recently to play for the Portland Thorns in the U.S.

Zach just signed an extension to 2025 five months ago in Nov, but I would guess he'd want to follow her back to the U.S. as well. Specifically to the Portland Timbers MLS side.

I have no other info on this other than Beckie left and you'd think he'd be joining her this summer. Unless she's on some very short term deal with the Thorns.

What about this one
 
Not sure why people think we need another forward if Jesus leaves. I’m guessing we won’t be able to sell Sterling due to his wages and preference of clubs, so he’ll go on a free next year. That leaves:

Haaland, Alvarez, Mahrez, Grealish, Sterling, Palmer for the forward line and that doesn’t include Foden who’s primarily played there the last two years or Delap (who I’m guessing we’ll try to loan out).

De Bruyne, Foden, Gundogan, Rodri, McAtee, Lavia, a new midfielder, and (hopefully) Bernardo.

Think Zinny will be off, so a new LB, Cancelo, Walker, and then a promotion for JWE and/or Kabore. CB’s stay as is and if Steffen wants to leave I think it’s more likely we bring in a veteran. Bazunu and Trafford should go on loan to get experience.
 
So how are you saying that he is comfortable in our system. I think Steffen is a very good goalkeeper, just not right for City.
He should be good in our system he was excellent in Germany passing through ball out
 
Not sure why people think we need another forward if Jesus leaves. I’m guessing we won’t be able to sell Sterling due to his wages and preference of clubs, so he’ll go on a free next year. That leaves:

Haaland, Alvarez, Mahrez, Grealish, Sterling, Palmer for the forward line and that doesn’t include Foden who’s primarily played there the last two years or Delap (who I’m guessing we’ll try to loan out).

De Bruyne, Foden, Gundogan, Rodri, McAtee, Lavia, a new midfielder, and (hopefully) Bernardo.

Think Zinny will be off, so a new LB, Cancelo, Walker, and then a promotion for JWE and/or Kabore. CB’s stay as is and if Steffen wants to leave I think it’s more likely we bring in a veteran. Bazunu and Trafford should go on loan to get experience.
Bazunu has a great future feeling we will sell him though as hes probably going to want to leave as top division clubs are interested.
 
He should be good in our system he was excellent in Germany passing through ball out
He may of been — can’t say I watched any of him but I have watched City games, where he has seemed nervy. The quality of the German league is very different to that of the Premier League. Steffen is fine against lesser opposition in domestic competitions but when we are in the latter stages against better opponents, we must play Ederson.
 
One bad game does not absolve the other he did in this season, very unfortunate the timing was not at the right time in important semi final match but he only just human.

You're asking the impossible wanting a backup as close in the quality as Ederson our main keeper, for the backup he the best we can get that willing to play a second GK where he could play elsewhere as main starter keeper.

Unless you want our club to pull PSG, paying absurd amount of money just to get a world class keeper as backup then forget it. There's more priority position that need to be strengthened first.
What we wanted was a fit ederson to play in a tough semi regardless of promises to cup keeper
 
What we wanted was a fit ederson to play in a tough semi regardless of promises to cup keeper
Sometimes you have to look at the bigger picture. Pep has decided probably for harmony purposes to give Steffan domestic cup duties as many clubs do.

When you take away that for the big games it will hit the moral of the player and likely other members of the squad, especially fringe players. We have seen this happen at United and Chelsea where they have full internationals being sidelined and looking to leave the clubs

You have to keep them involved in pressured games or you will have a problem if you lose your no1 keeper going forward.
 
He should be good in our system he was excellent in Germany passing through ball out

?? No he wasn't. He had a number of high profile blunders and when we brought him back I remember American pundits being surprised because his passing was a known weakness.

There's a good article here breaking down his poor playing out from the back from 2019 - https://archive.ph/OeuuH

The problem for Steffen is this isn't a one off. Remember last year he picked up a back pass against Chelsea because he panicked and then lost his head compeltely for Ziyech's goal, standing 10 foot wide of the goal completely lost.


He's probably a really nice guy and will be a decent keeper somewhere else, but he will never replace Ederson long term and we'd have to completely change our style of play if Eddie picked up an injury so I don't know what he's doing here.
 
Last edited:
I think the main issue here is that promising the back up keeper the League Cup and some FA Cup games should be enough, I'm not sure why he needs to be promised nearly 15 games.

I've also always really disliked the idea that Ederson wouldn't win a treble if we won all 3 competitions. You're not officially an FA Cup winner without playing so Eddie wouldn't be part of a treble or quadruple, which is bollocks.
 
Sometimes you have to look at the bigger picture. Pep has decided probably for harmony purposes to give Steffan domestic cup duties as many clubs do.

When you take away that for the big games it will hit the moral of the player and likely other members of the squad, especially fringe players. We have seen this happen at United and Chelsea where they have full internationals being sidelined and looking to leave the clubs

You have to keep them involved in pressured games or you will have a problem if you lose your no1 keeper going forward.

Yeah we never know if Ederson get nasty injury without we knowing (I hope he never have), we need backup keeper feel the pressure of high profile match to keep them focus. Yeah there will be always a risk but the benefit will be huge long term just like you said.

Really good thing that none of our fans (including me) in charge of the player in team, otherwise we will lose dressing room easily.
 
He may of been — can’t say I watched any of him but I have watched City games, where he has seemed nervy. The quality of the German league is very different to that of the Premier League. Steffen is fine against lesser opposition in domestic competitions but when we are in the latter stages against better opponents, we must play Ederson.
The German league is probably the best league after our own using that logic we should only buy players from other premier league clubs. I don’t know what it is nerves lack of games but I don’t believe he is a bad player or not suited to our system. I trust the people who scouted him and the clips I have seen of him pulling off amazing saves and passing the ball like Ederson
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top