Man_City_Loyal
Well-Known Member
Was all mentioned at the time
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
47 | Phil Foden - 2024/25
- Thread starter Vienna_70
- Start date
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
Was all mentioned at the time
sir baconface
Well-Known Member
Was all mentioned at the time
Just as I thought.
I knew you’d have no supporting data but fondly imagined you might at least make an attempt at the other two questions.
Last edited:
You've just named five or maybe even six players who will (should) be gone in the summer. Add USA bound KDB to that list too.
There's a big difference between loss of form and loss / lack of ability/intensity at top level.
To be honest, Phil has been as bad as, if not worse than, most of those you’ve named this season.
The important thing is that time on his side and, unless he does a Michael Johnson on us (heaven forbid), he'll be fine in the long term.
The difference is Phil is reigning POTY, and has improved pretty linearly for 6/7 years in a row. I thought this season he might make a jump up to megastar, but I think I also wrote that he’s due a dud season and maybe this is it.
That Foden has an illness affecting his form is speculation. He, Pep and City coaching staff will know all about his physical state and ability to play. The simple fact is he is paid to play and perform like in any job so what is wrong?he's clearly got an illness that effecting this season it's been pretty much said in jacks article which you have completely bi passed
My observation is now we rarely see him smile which indicates all is not well be it mental or physical, on or off the field, football or domestic. It is best kept private and I am sure support is there to help get him back on track but ultimately it is down to him so no point in speculating.
thomas1307
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 21 Nov 2024
- Messages
- 514
- Team supported
- manchester city
the fact is so many people can see something isn't right with him but guess what you still get fans slagging him off even though they can see there's issues going onThat Foden has an illness affecting his form is speculation. He, Pep and City coaching staff will know all about his physical state and ability to play. The simple fact is he is paid to play and perform like in any job so what is wrong?
My observation is now we rarely see him smile which indicates all is not well be it mental or physical, on or off the field, football or domestic. It is best kept private and I am sure support is there to help get him back on track but ultimately it is down to him so no point in speculating.
Ellenbrook_blue
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 22 Feb 2015
- Messages
- 148
Apologies I got the year wrongThe appendicitis operation was in March 2023. After that, he had a great season and was named POTY last season.
These are just another excuses.
Lavinda Past
Well-Known Member
he's clearly got an illness that effecting this season it's been pretty much said in jacks article which you have completely bi passed
I usually ignore much of what's said by players. They're invariably following the party line, and any 'inconvenient truths' tend to be washed over.
eastmanc
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 7 Nov 2010
- Messages
- 10,286
- Team supported
- Manchester city
You don't lose your ability you lose your legs.You've just named five or maybe even six players who will (should) be gone in the summer. Add USA bound KDB to that list too.
There's a big difference between loss of form and loss / lack of ability/intensity at top level.
To be honest, Phil has been as bad as, if not worse than, most of those you’ve named this season.
The important thing is that time on his side and, unless he does a Michael Johnson on us (heaven forbid), he'll be fine in the long term.
I don't do sentiment when it comes to overindulged multi millionaires. They can look after themselves.
Great assist from this overindulged millionaire now he’s actually playing in a position he likes. Bellingham off & we score 2 goals
Assist yes.Great assist from this overindulged millionaire now he’s actually playing in a position he likes. Bellingham off & we score 2 goals
Great?
Thats just a routine pass from a midfielder to his winger who is completely in his line of sight with no opposition.
That was all Eze.
Assist yes.
Great?
Thats just a routine pass from a midfielder to his winger who is completely in his line of sight with no opposition.
That was all Eze.
It was spot on distance-wise & speed. Give credit where it’s due mate. He is a Blue after all - you don’t have to feel uncomfortable about it
Its a routine simple pass.It was spot on distance-wise & speed. Give credit where it’s due mate. He is a Blue after all - you don’t have to feel uncomfortable about it
Im not uncomfortable, Ive been Phils biggest supporter.
But your over the top in praise for simple things does him a disservice.
Its a routine simple pass.
Im not uncomfortable, Ive been Phils biggest supporter.
But your over the top in praise for simple things does him a disservice.
Where’s my over the top praise? I just acknowledged a great pass - why’s it upset you so much
Lavinda Past
Well-Known Member
You don't lose your ability you lose your legs.
You know what I meant. Same thing at the end of the day.
Well you said great assist, it wasnt, just a routine simple pass.Where’s my over the top praise? I just acknowledged a great pass - why’s it upset you so much
Not upset, Im just pointing out your hypocrisy.
There are people who stupidly go in one direction claiming to want phil sold over this season, but equally, we dont neee ppl glazing him over simple stuff in the complete opposite direction.
Looked reasonably sharp when he came on tonight. Granted it was only Latvia, but encouraging signs nonetheless. Hopefully he can put whatever problems he is facing behind him, and return to last season’s form soon.
Yes - definitely better when he’s not stuck out on the wing
How does that help us if he moves to Stockport county ?Needs to move back to Stockport area where he feels more at home and make him happy again.
Lavinda Past
Well-Known Member
How does that help us if he moves to Stockport county ?
We'd get a percentage of any sell-on fee?
- Status
- Not open for further replies.