Alexander Isak | Cried his way to a £130m move

The whole point of bringing in a quality striker is so Haaland doesn't have to play every minute of every game until his body breaks like Rodri's has.

Again, Moose isn't a specialist striker. His goals & assists are vital from playing behind, or to the left of the main striker.

Haalands going to play 90% of games. He's the face of the club on a half a mill a week 10 year deal. Isak can go to Liverpool and be the undisputed main man. Its impossible to have two strikers worth over 100 million in the same team with one spot in the starting line up.

Now if we had never sold Delap and he was at his current level in the squad, great that would be useful, but we don't.

Marmoush is perfect as he can play on either wing or in the 10 when Erling is starting and the 9 when he isn't. Is he better off the left? Sure, but he's a much better striker than Isak or Ekitike are left wingers.

For me I don't really give a shit about any of Liverpool's signings. Only Kerkez improves them. I don't think Wirtz has the physicality to succeed in England, Diaz and Jota used to give me kittens so I'll take anyone coming in for them as a big downgrade. Frimpong is about as good a defender as TAA but nowhere near the creative influence.

They might all work out great, might not, same as us.
 
The whole point of bringing in a quality striker is so Haaland doesn't have to play every minute of every game until his body breaks like Rodri's has.

Again, Moose isn't a specialist striker. His goals & assists are vital from playing behind, or to the left of the main striker.
Yet the season before we signed Haaland we somehow managed to win the league (scoring 99 goals, 150 in all comps) and got to the semi's of the FA & CL cups. All that without a "specialist striker". Somehow I think we'll manage.
 
So we rinse Haaland dry over 60+ games then? Have we learned nothing from the Rodri situation where similar sentiments were proffered prior to his body breaking? Again, Moose isn't a striker.

Suggesting that Moose can "do a job" "put a shift in" or "will be fine" are similar arguments I heard put forward after Kompany left & Rodri got injured.

In both instances, consider how the following season unfolded, & the signings City made in the proceeding windows to correct the glaring deficiencies in our squad after the "we'll be OK" & the player A, B or C "can do a job" stances, crashed & burned?

We're Manchester City & "can do a job" shouldn't be anywhere near being a solution for us. Rodri? Kovacic "can do a job". Walker? Nunes "can do a job". We ended up winning nowt & were nearly relegated from the Champions League. That's where "can do a job" gets you mate.
So who do you suggest we sign, genius?
 
There getting him ,and all this fucking about when we were top dogs and did fuck all ,and buying utter shite worrying about PSR is going to bite us on the arse big time .Well run club ,do me a favour.
 
There getting him ,and all this fucking about when we were top dogs and did fuck all ,and buying utter shite worrying about PSR is going to bite us on the arse big time .Well run club ,do me a favour.

Just going to get in with the first wave - we've literally dominated the Premier League and English football for the best part of a decade. Yeah we've made some missteps recently (I was crying out for a midfielder last summer) but we are well ran. Best coach ever, current Ballon D'or winner etc
 
There getting him ,and all this fucking about when we were top dogs and did fuck all ,and buying utter shite worrying about PSR is going to bite us on the arse big time .Well run club ,do me a favour.
Pathetic- cry me a river. How old are you? Sound like you are having a hissy fit. If we win the title again this season it’s hardly like spoilt brats like you deserve it.
 
Haalands going to play 90% of games. He's the face of the club on a half a mill a week 10 year deal. Isak can go to Liverpool and be the undisputed main man. Its impossible to have two strikers worth over 100 million in the same team with one spot in the starting line up.

Now if we had never sold Delap and he was at his current level in the squad, great that would be useful, but we don't.

Marmoush is perfect as he can play on either wing or in the 10 when Erling is starting and the 9 when he isn't. Is he better off the left? Sure, but he's a much better striker than Isak or Ekitike are left wingers.

For me I don't really give a shit about any of Liverpool's signings. Only Kerkez improves them. I don't think Wirtz has the physicality to succeed in England, Diaz and Jota used to give me kittens so I'll take anyone coming in for them as a big downgrade. Frimpong is about as good a defender as TAA but nowhere near the creative influence.

They might all work out great, might not, same as us.
Do you really believe Haaland would be pissed if he was left out of the squad for a rest, as we face Ipswich, Sheffield Utd or Burnley et al at home in the PL, or Lincoln City away in the Carabao Cup?

Big players want to play in the biggest games. That's why we need to utilise our squad to its fullest extent so they can be rotated & rested for lower profile matches.

Regardless of some fans believing that every player wants to play every minute of every game, otherwise there'd be a transfer request incoming, this isn't borne out by the facts. After the treble, Rodri warned that he feared for his health because of the amount of games he was expected to play. His worst fears were realised.

Several players lamented about taking part in the CWC because they needed a rest. Akanji said most of our squad would've preferred the summer off instead of competing in the CWC.

Foden complained about the physical & mental fatigue he was suffering from last season. Bernardo said the players would prefer a larger squad to ease the playing pressure on them.

The only City player I can recall kicking up a proper stink about not playing every game was Cancelo. But he's a mental case who kicked off over the same thing at most clubs he's played at.

Other players who'd fallen out of favour so were not playing as often as they'd like, so wanting a move for more hame time, is a different matter. Players like Sterling, Zinchenko, Jesus, Laporte etc come to mind.

Our players are human beings, not robots. The only person ever to state they prefer a small squad is Pep. I've never heard a player state a small squad was their preference.

If Pep wants to compete for the four major trophies every season, we'll need a bigger squad. We saw the effect that rinsing out a small elite squad season after season had throughout 2024-25. It devastated our squad & made our season imploded.

We can't continue to do this. Something has to change.
 
Do you really believe Haaland would be pissed if he was left out of the squad for a rest, as we face Ipswich, Sheffield Utd or Burnley et al at home in the PL, or Lincoln City away in the Carabao Cup?

Big players want to play in the biggest games. That's why we need to utilise our squad to its fullest extent so they can be rotated & rested for lower profile matches.

Regardless of some fans believing that every player wants to play every minute of every game, otherwise there'd be a transfer request incoming, this isn't borne out by the facts. After the treble, Rodri warned that he feared for his health because of the amount of games he was expected to play. His worst fears were realised.

Several players lamented about taking part in the CWC because they needed a rest. Foden complained about the physical & mental fatigue he was suffering from last season. Akanji said most of our squad would've preferred the summer off. Bernardo said the players would prefer a larger squad to ease the playing pressure on them.

The only City player I can recall kicking up a proper stink about not playing every game was Cancelo. But he's a mental case who kicked off over the same thing at most clubs he's played at.

Other players who'd fallen out of favour so were not playing as often as they'd like, so wanting a move for more hame time, is a different matter. Players like Sterling, Zinchenko, Jesus, Laporte etc come to mind.

Our players are human beings, not robots. The only person ever to state they prefer a small squad is Pep. I've never heard a player state a small squad was their preference.

If Pep wants to compete for the four major trophies every season, we'll need a bigger squad. We saw the effect that rinsing out a small elite squad season after season had throughout 2024-25. It devastated our squad & made our season imploded.

We can't continue to do this & something has to change.


We are told that players believe that they are playing too much football and then we are told they are upset if they get left out, which one is it? Fuck knows!

If we bring another expensive striker in and we rotate I suspect it would piss off one or the other.
 
Yet the season before we signed Haaland we somehow managed to win the league (scoring 99 goals, 150 in all comps) and got to the semi's of the FA & CL cups. All that without a "specialist striker". Somehow I think we'll manage.
By that metric, with us having an elite striker in Haaland, we should have made it 5 in a row & completed the quadruple. Why didn't we?
 
Last edited:
So who do you suggest we sign, genius?
Going by your metric, we only need 11 elite players in the squad. This way they can all play every minute of every game. That should keep that 11 & yourself happy shouldn't it?

We don't need to concern ourselves with insignificant things like injuries, fatigue, loss of form or suspensions should we, because those 11 players will still drag their battered carcasses across the chalk line to spill blood for Pep.

You cool with that?
 
Hence why we need to trim the fat. Pep says he wants a smaller squad, but he seems determined to cling on to his tried & tested, but ultimately ageing & constantly injured players.

We both agree that our squad needs two elite strikers to compete, rest & rotate with each other. Having no space in the squad is purely down to poor squad planning on Pep's behalf after we won the treble.

It was obvious then that our squad was in need of evolution. We essentially tinkered with it for two seasons, meaning the evolution quickly turned into a badly needed revolution.

It was all so unnecessary mate. If we want to compete on all four fronts every season, we're gonna need to maximise our squad size, & strengthen its gene pool.
Don't disagree with you with any of that. My only counter point is there's no fat to trim in an attacking department thats already full. Marmoush was the Alvarez replacement, he doesnt look like a good fit in that role (hopefully he'll learn it) but hes excelled off the left so we've added him to the list of options behind haaland but we can't add another.

Yet the season before we signed Haaland we somehow managed to win the league (scoring 99 goals, 150 in all comps) and got to the semi's of the FA & CL cups. All that without a "specialist striker". Somehow I think we'll manage.
Do you think doku, Savinho, cherki and marmoush could score the 73 goals that kdb, sterling, mahrez and Jesus got for us that season? I wouldn't be confident they'd get half.
 
Don't disagree with you with any of that. My only counter point is there's no fat to trim in an attacking department thats already full. Marmoush was the Alvarez replacement, he doesnt look like a good fit in that role (hopefully he'll learn it) but hes excelled off the left so we've added him to the list of options behind haaland but we can't add another.


Do you think doku, Savinho, cherki and marmoush could score the 73 goals that kdb, sterling, mahrez and Jesus got for us that season? I wouldn't be confident they'd get half.
I do think the squad we have will score 100 ish PL goals next season. If we don’t win the league next season it won’t be because we need another striker.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top