Veganism

Just had a lovely rib eye with chips and fried onions. I think the potato was still alive when I cut it into chips as a shoot was just appearing on its surface. The steak was dead though.
 
I admit liking meat. I wouldn't force it on anyone except my own kids who in my opinion need it. I would kill the chicken, remove it's feathers and insides, light a fire and roast it in a heartbeat. Survival of the fittest. I'd do the same to a cow, lamb, pig, whatever. Because I can. Might need a big knife for a cow. And that's not selfish. That's how things are. That's how things have developed to be. What I really disagree with is any vegan/vegetarian claiming the moral high ground because they eat dead vegetables instead of dead animals. You made a choice so fuck off home. Don't preach to me about how holier than fucking thou you are just because you eat different dead shit than I do.

We disagree no big thing I could counter argue pretty much everything you said but it would be futile, it's only a debate anyhow
 
It was a bit of a rollercoaster and I should have come at it from a different angle. I'd had a bad day before I started the thread. People, including myself, got wound up and I can see why. Hey ho, hopefully it had some worth in it somewhere. I'm sorry for any offence caused to anyone. Funny, it really does read like I went out of my way to call random strangers selfish.. but that wasn't the point at all.

Turncoat
 
It was a bit of a rollercoaster and I should have come at it from a different angle. I'd had a bad day before I started the thread. People, including myself, got wound up and I can see why. Hey ho, hopefully it had some worth in it somewhere. I'm sorry for any offence caused to anyone. Funny, it really does read like I went out of my way to call random strangers selfish.. but that wasn't the point at all.

Top post, loads of respect for that mate. You're entitled to your views and of course are passionate about them but seeing outside the own argument is an incredibly rare trait. Could do with another 100 of you on here recently.
 
My kids are both veggie too
*calls social services to save you the bother*
How dare you deprive your very own children the delights of a pepperoni pizza, a cheese and ham toasty, a bacon and egg butty or even a glass of milk and few biscuits? You're harsh ammy.
 
I consider animals a lower form of life than us as they lack consciousness and even rudimentary intelligence. They're essentially walking plants who we prescribe human values and behaviours to because it satiates our nurturing desire, biologically programmed to release endorphins and happy thoughts into us so we don't just leave our kids in the middle of a bush somewhere. The science behind what animals we find cute and not cute, edible and inedible is mostly about how they share similar characteristics to children.

I'm absolutely a speciest. I'd wipe out every white tailed deer in the world if it cured cancer and do it without a moment's hesitation.

The biggest evolutionary benefit to an animal now is to be useful to humans. That isn't even a debate, it's a fact as anybody who has looked at global chicken and populations or the decline of the global horse population over the past 100 years will attest to. We keep them and breed them in order to satisfy our hunger. The ones that irritate us are generally wiped out on a global scale unless they serve some purpose that we have identified.

Too many humans think they're above nature and because they have developed consciousness the rules just don't apply any longer. I say that's nonsense and a look at the ecological record shows it to be ignorant nonsense. We're still under the development of evolution, we're still shaping nature to fit us and adapting to the new conditions no different from any other animal on the planet. Animals constantly and consistently uproot and wipe out populations of other animals. We're just better at it then they are.

I don't have compassion for animals because I don't have compassion for bacteria, or viruses, or plants and see them ranked along the same lines. This doesn't mean I don't love my dog or have a collection of cat skulls in my basement, it means that although I love my dog I recognise it as ultimately inferior to every human being alive by almost every metric apart from my own sentimentality borne out of what is essentially my own invention.
Vulcanism 1 Veganism 0
 
It was a bit of a rollercoaster and I should have come at it from a different angle. I'd had a bad day before I started the thread. People, including myself, got wound up and I can see why. Hey ho, hopefully it had some worth in it somewhere. I'm sorry for any offence caused to anyone. Funny, it really does read like I went out of my way to call random strangers selfish.. but that wasn't the point at all.
Fair play mate no harm done really. You'll keep eating vegetables and I'll keep eating meat, fish, eggs and vegetables. No big deal.
 
Go on then have a go. Stand by everything I typed in that.

I accept you believe everything you said, as I stated it would be a futile task on my behalf, we will both be eating a bacon sarnie tomorrow no matter how illogical I find your reasoning for it
 
I accept you believe everything you said, as I stated it would be a futile task on my behalf, we will both be eating a bacon sarnie tomorrow no matter how illogical I find your reasoning for it
I just find it illogical to determine one aspect of the farming industry off limits while the other is a okay and even gives some kind of deluded morality high ground over others that are no different than them, just eat different stuff.

The real question is what sauce you'll use on your bacon butty tomorrow...
 
I just find it illogical to determine one aspect of the farming industry off limits while the other is a okay and even gives some kind of deluded morality high ground over others that are no different than them, just eat different stuff.

The real question is what sauce you'll use on your bacon butty tomorrow...

Brown and only brown, red sauce on bacon butties is for 3 year olds and yanks
 
Great thread - I've read the lot more or less

To put it bluntly, we are top of the food chain and can do what we want!

As posted earlier, if we all stopped eating meat tomorrow there would be allsorts of social problems and when you balance that with the welfare of pigs, cows etc the cattles welfare doesn't come close

I my opinion, you can't have it both ways - you can't be a vegan(and preach) yet in the next breath kill a fly, spider etc
 
People tend to laugh at this, and I don't really see what's funny.

I feel like once you know the facts of your existence, you are logically obligated to not eat meat or dairy/perpetuate suffering you know is happening. In basically the same way you wouldn't yourself want to be farmed, tortured, live a miserable life, and have a miserable death. Vegans cause less harm, that's just how it is.

Life arose in a cesspit billions of years ago and has been evolving ever since with no intelligence or any compassion for sentient life whatsoever. Life is imposed, so you have no choice in playing the game, you just suddenly arrive on planet Earth. We grow up seeing nature at work, and some people think it's beautiful, which is strange because we all know the miseries that happen to sentient creatures every second. Most of which we can nothing about, but the bit we can do something about though (because we're smart) is the harm that we cause.

I am utterly ashamed when I think of all the meat I've eaten and how unquestioning and selfish I was. In what world, when there is plenty of stuff to eat, (and no, I am not having it that a lettuce has the capacity to feel pain like animal does) does it make any sense to exploit others?

Would beings more intelligent than ourselves cause needless suffering? I don't think so.

Can someone rationally justify themselves eating meat? Or are you forced to admit that you are just an ignorant/selfish person?

well to go back to the OP - I don't see why firstly I should be LEGALLY obliged ( not obligated ) not to eat meat or dairy. Its not illegal ergo I am not obliged not to eat it. Yes I agree I am actively encouraged to do so by the way the world is run however I still do so out of choice. I say that because I like you have a choice.
I can justify eating meat on various nutritional, health and economic reasons . I don't laugh at vegans or vegetarians - I ave a vegetarian sister and daughter - however I don't seek to preach to them how my food choices should in some way take precedence over theirs. In fact thats not something I can recall any omnivore doing - yet oddly enough it seems to be the default position of most vegetarians and almost all vegans I meet - for some reason they can't wait to tell me how they are right and I am wrong .... and why.
I am not selfish - I am not ignorant - I am hungry and chose to fill my belly and that of my family - those who chose to do likewise - in a perfectly legal no preachy way with which I am perfectly happy thank you.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top