Players season ratings

U U

uwe rosler 28

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 Jan 2009
Messages
9,224
Location
Abbey Hey
I know there's 1 game to go but my ratings won't change what are yours?

Hart 7/10 good solid season bit more concentration needed
Willy 6/10 will be remembered for his heroics at Wembley but can't forget spurs away!
zabba 3/10 injuries took there toll on him a shadow of his past!
sagna 7/10 good solid season definitely deserves another year
demi 2/10 too old now
otamendi 6/10 looks awesome 1 game and a liability the next
mangala 5/10 as above
vinny 4/10 mark due to injuries think he's finished hope to god im wrong!
clichy 7/10 one of the most underrated at the club needs better distribution!
Kolarov 4/10 plays when he can arsed city carear over
navas 6/10 100% every week lacks top quality
Fernando 6/10 a little unlucky not to play more games needs better distribution!
Fernandiniho 6/10 100% most weeks terrible passer!
yaya 4/10 age caught up with him lazy but will be a legend always in my eyes
nasri 4/10 mark due to injuries think he might have a part to play under pep
silva 5/10 very poor season by his standards
sterling 4/10 mark would have been worse but for his performances in Europe!
Delph 2/10 utter garbage but has been played out of position a lot
kdb 6/10 good debut season went missing in a lot of big games early in season seems to have picked that up!
nacho 8/10 1 positive to come from the season a star of the future
aguero 8/10 not at his best but his goalscoring record is something else
bony -1/10 had to save the best till last!
 
Aguero, Fernandinho, Hart 7's

Sagna, Iheanacho and Navas 6's

The rest can middle from 2-4's.
 
I will use your list edited to keep it simple, it does show my opinion of the season....

Hart 7/10
Willy 5/10 (10/10 for one game but shite the rest)
zabba 4/10
sagna 8/10
demi 1/10
otamendi 5/10
mangala 5/10
vinny 4/10
clichy 8/10
Kolarov 2/10
navas 6/10
Fernando 6/10
Fernandinho 6/10
yaya 3/10
nasri 3/10
silva 5/10
sterling 3/10
Delph 3/10
kdb 8/10
nacho 8/10
aguero 8/10
bony 1/10

So in reality, the only ones to come out with any credit for the season for me are Sagna, Clichy, Kev, Sergio and Nacho.
 
Rammy Blue said:
I will use your list edited to keep it simple, it does show my opinion of the season....

Hart 7/10
Willy 5/10 (10/10 for one game but shite the rest)
zabba 4/10
sagna 8/10
demi 1/10
otamendi 5/10
mangala 5/10
vinny 4/10
clichy 8/10
Kolarov 2/10
navas 6/10
Fernando 6/10
Fernandinho 6/10
yaya 3/10
nasri 3/10
silva 5/10
sterling 3/10
Delph 3/10
kdb 8/10
nacho 8/10
aguero 8/10
bony 1/10

So in reality, the only ones to come out with any credit for the season for me are Sagna, Clichy, Kev, Sergio and Nacho.
Click to expand...
Extremely harsh on Fernandinho and too kind on Silva who has been as disinterested and unwilling to work hard as anyone, but the rest I more or less agree with.
 
Hart --7-- decent season could win another golden boot even with the terrible defence ahead of him.
Willy --5-- Apart from Wembley he's been poor. Needs replacing.
Zaba --4-- Looks to be over at City for Zabs gutted. Needs replacing.
Sagna --7-- Solid all season long. Agree he deserves anot her year.
Demi --0-- Down to manager to old & slow. Needs replacing.
Otamendi --5-- Good then bad.
Mangala --5-- As above.
Vinny --3-- Shame about Vinny he's been out biggest loss. Probably needs replacing.
Clichy --6-- Steady season.
Kolarov --3-- Cray needs replacing.
Navas --6-- Quite like Navas, but he can frustrate.
Fernando --6-- Improved quite a lot.
Fernandiniho --7-- Great all around energy.
Yaya --4-- Another player done. Needs replacing.
Nasri --3--All down to his injury. Will play under Pep Imo.
Silva --4-- Another player who's suffered with injures.
Sterling --5-- decent return of goals but work rate is shite. Needs to improve.
Delph --4-- Played out of poss & Injured.
KDB --8-- Quality with plenty to come.
Nacho --7-- The rising star.
Aguero --9-- Never let's us down.
Bony --0-- We got robbed. Needs replacing.

Willy, Zabs, Demi, Vinny (possibly) Kola rover & Yaya all need replacing.
 
uwe rosler 28 said:
I know there's 1 game to go but my ratings won't change what are yours?

Hart 7/10 good solid season bit more concentration needed
Willy 6/10 will be remembered for his heroics at Wembley but can't forget spurs away!
zabba 3/10 injuries took there toll on him a shadow of his past!
sagna 7/10 good solid season definitely deserves another year
demi 2/10 too old now
otamendi 6/10 looks awesome 1 game and a liability the next
mangala 5/10 as above
vinny 4/10 mark due to injuries think he's finished hope to god im wrong!
clichy 7/10 one of the most underrated at the club needs better distribution!
Kolarov 4/10 plays when he can arsed city carear over
navas 6/10 100% every week lacks top quality
Fernando 6/10 a little unlucky not to play more games needs better distribution!
Fernandiniho 6/10 100% most weeks terrible passer!
yaya 4/10 age caught up with him lazy but will be a legend always in my eyes
nasri 4/10 mark due to injuries think he might have a part to play under pep
silva 5/10 very poor season by his standards
sterling 4/10 mark would have been worse but for his performances in Europe!
Delph 2/10 utter garbage but has been played out of position a lot
kdb 6/10 good debut season went missing in a lot of big games early in season seems to have picked that up!
nacho 8/10 1 positive to come from the season a star of the future
aguero 8/10 not at his best but his goalscoring record is something else
bony -1/10 had to save the best till last!
Click to expand...
Do you actually watch City ? If so how the fuck can you only give Fernandinho 6.Absolutely startling Jeff.
 
Hart 6
Willy 4
zabba 4
sagna 6
demi 1
otamendi 5
mangala 5
vinny 4
clichy 7
Kolarov 0
navas 5
Fernando 6
Fernandinho 6
yaya 2
nasri 5
silva 5
sterling 2
Delph 3
kdb 8
nacho 7
aguero 7
bony 1
 
Rammy Blue said:
I will use your list edited to keep it simple, it does show my opinion of the season....

Hart 7/10
Willy 5/10 (10/10 for one game but shite the rest)
zabba 4/10
sagna 8/10
demi 1/10
otamendi 5/10
mangala 5/10
vinny 4/10
clichy 8/10
Kolarov 2/10
navas 6/10
Fernando 6/10
Fernandinho 6/10
yaya 3/10
nasri 3/10
silva 5/10
sterling 3/10
Delph 3/10
kdb 8/10
nacho 8/10
aguero 8/10
bony 1/10

So in reality, the only ones to come out with any credit for the season for me are Sagna, Clichy, Kev, Sergio and Nacho.
Click to expand...

Only differences to yours would be up a mark each to 7 for both the Ferns and down a mark for Nacho (he hasn't been that effing good, especially outside the box!).
As regard the centre half situation, yesterday just about convinced me that if we decide to offload one of either Mangler or Otters, then the former should be the one to go. They're both error strewn, but Mangala in possession and under pressure makes me shit my pants
 
I think some people are watching from so high up that they think Delph has been Fernandinho.
 
Hart 7/10
Willy 3/10 (10/10 for one game but shite the rest)
zabba 3/10
sagna 7/10
demi 1/10
otamendi 6/10
mangala 7/10
vinny 8/10
clichy 8/10
Kolarov 4/10
navas 5/10
Fernando 4/10
Fernandinho 7/10
yaya 5/10
nasri 7/10
silva 6/10
sterling 5/10
Delph 4/10
kdb 7/10
nacho 8/10
aguero 8/10
bony 1/10
 
Exeter Blue I am here said:
Only differences to yours would be up a mark each to 7 for both the Ferns and down a mark for Nacho (he hasn't been that effing good, especially outside the box!).
As regard the centre half situation, yesterday just about convinced me that if we decide to offload one of either Mangler or Otters, then the former should be the one to go. They're both error strewn, but Mangala in possession and under pressure makes me shit my pants
Click to expand...
Yeah, maybe slightly harsh on the Ferns but just the inconsistency of Nando and the fact that I know Dinho is better than what we see. Agree about Nacho but it was more about the promise as well, his goal return for the start of his career is good.
 
Hart 7: some brilliant games some poor
Sagna:7: Brilliant defender, great in champions league, not great going forward
Kompany 9: When he played
Otamendi 6: rash in challenges but some brilliant tackles and interceptions
Mangala6: crap on the ball but some good defending
Kolarov 1: get him out!
Demichelis: N/A
Clichy 7: injured at the start bad passer
Zabaleta 5: hero but time to go, sagnas kept him out
Fernando 7: very bad performances until dinamo kyiv but brilliant otherwise(bad mistake against psg)
Fernandinho 9: best player this season with his energy
Toure 3: glimpses of his old self. A liability when he plays
KDB 8: Looks unstoppable some games in others he's non existant
Navas 6: works very hard. No end product
Silva6: unlucky with ankle injury all season
Sterling 6: Great in Chmapions League
Nasri 6: you dont know what your going to get
Iheanacho 8: big future but should have passed against arsenal(lack of experience)
Bony:4: has to go.
Aguero 9: his brilliant self in league would be lost without him
Pellegrini 5: let us down in league but amazing in europe especially against Sevilla
 
Last edited:
Hart 7/10 - Big improvement on last year, often let down by defending.
Willy 6/10 - He has probably played what 5 games, one of which gave us a trophy.
zabba 5/10 - Mostly absent and has had good games but some really terrible ones too.
sagna 6/10 - Decent but caught out at times, will see what Pep makes of him.
demi 2/10 - Should of gone last year unfortunately.
otamendi 6/10 - Decent enough and looked a great signing, the managers tactics and ignorance to defending let him down.
mangala 6/10 - Has looked solid in some games, an accident waiting to happen the next, he's still young yet.
vinny 5/10 - Has had some terrible games and more so injuries, looked good recently but he can't seem to get 90 minutes. He'll be back.
clichy 7/10 - Much improved over last year where Kolarov was better.
Kolarov 5/10 - Not bad, not good though, same as the rest of our defence really, good game one week an awful one the next.
navas 6/10 - You can't argue he doesn't try and hasn't done his best, will forever be remembered for his final ball...
Fernando 7/10 - Poor sometimes but the best player of the last month or so with the other Fern.
Fernandinho 7/10 - If not KDB he would get player of the season for me, has given his all again this year and was vital in our CL run.
yaya 4/10 - Good start but his performances over the last few months have been flat at best.
nasri 6 - Can't say much because of injuries but was good at the start and has had a few decent games recently.
silva 5/10 - Injuries again, one good game followed by a bad one, really missed his quality this year.
sterling 5/10 - OK, looked quality at the start of the season but has looked out of his depth these last few months. Needs time.
Delph 5/10 - Looks a good signing, mobile in midfield but still a bit young and naive.
kdb 8/10 - Just about consistent enough and has showed flashes of shear brilliance, player of the season for me.
nacho 7/10 - Good goalscorer but has looked completely out of his depth recently. Another who needs time.
aguero 8/10 - Take away his injuries and he would probably be top scorer, has been absent in the bigger games though.
bony 3/10 - Has had some game time and just doesn't seem to fit in the side unfortunately.
 
Fernandinho 8/10 been are best player by a mile , as others have mentioned Hart , Sagna , Clichy , Ginger Kev and Aguero have had decent seasons
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top