You gave Kolarov far too high score
Aguero 10 without him were doomed
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Players season ratings
- Thread starter uwe rosler 28
- Start date
Aguero 10 without him were doomed
malg
Well-Known Member
I see Silva is getting his usual Bluemoon free pass. That ankle injury must have lasted 2 years!
Tricky_Trev
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 18 Jan 2009
- Messages
- 32,342
Well from most yes. I said above that he's been as lazy as anyone in the squad and I stand by that. People completely overlook his quarter-arsed attempts to win the ball or track a runner (or even to track a jogger), but chastise Yaya for similar things. I think Silva's had a terrible season. Most seem to disagree and have him at an 'average' season, but he's been 3 or 4 out of 10 in my opinion. For what little that's worth! :)I see Silva is getting his usual Bluemoon free pass. That ankle injury must have lasted 2 years!
Hart (8): Some unbelievable saves and he's become a real leader in the dressing room, just wish his distribution was better.
Willy (5): It would be zero but for the cup final, chuffed for the lad though because the other players clearly like him.
Sagna (6.5): Very solid defensively but sadly doesn't offer us anything going forward.
Otamendi (6): Some outstanding performances, some mind boggling charges out of position but the lack of protection from midfield leaves all our defenders susceptible at times.
Mangala (6): As above.
Clichy (7.5): He comes out of this season with real credit for me. Works his socks off and I think Pep will love his pressing and intercepting ability.
Demichellis (1): The single worst top division performance I have ever witnessed, totally lost his head and it wouldn't surprise me if he retired this summer. Completely out of his depth at his age.
Kolarov (3): Started the season on fire, looked bang up for it and was defending with purpose. Since then he's given up and let Clichy win the battle of the left backs.
Zabaleta, Kompany unmarked due to injury.
Fernando (6.5): Very poor technically at times but you can't fault his heart and commitment, if he continues playing like he is lately he could force his way into Guardiola's plans.
Fernandinho (8.5): Absolutely immense, love him. Again I can't wait to see what Guardiola will make of him, can see him playing a very similar role to Vidal at Bayern.
Yaya (2): Moments of spectacular brilliance but dominated by lazy, half arsed performances and it's completely killed our ability to press as a team. Poorly utilised by Pellegrini but equally Yaya's effort is very questionable at best.
Delph unmarked due to injury and being played out of position.
Navas (4): Love the guys work rate and commitment but he's an attacking player who doesn't score or assist goals, don't see the point of him.
Sterling (5): Poor season and he's lost his confidence by being asked to play too safe in my opinion but Pep will get the best out of him I have absolutely no doubt.
De Bruyne (8.5): Wow, what a fucking player. Took a few games to settle and doesn't look half the player out wide but played in the middle behind Aguero he looks immense.
Silva and Nasri unmarked due to injury.
Aguero (9): Just sheer class, nothing more to say on the little fella.
Iheanacho (7.5): Brilliant first season and I just hope he kicks on again under Pep. We have to accept that as a kid still he's going to be inconsistent but boy he's got the talent.
Bony (2): Looks half interested and I can't wait for him to fuck off in all honesty. Such a shame because the lad clearly has ability, just don't understand what has gone wrong. He could have been the perfect stand in/different option when Aguero isn't working.
Probably missed a couple out.
Willy (5): It would be zero but for the cup final, chuffed for the lad though because the other players clearly like him.
Sagna (6.5): Very solid defensively but sadly doesn't offer us anything going forward.
Otamendi (6): Some outstanding performances, some mind boggling charges out of position but the lack of protection from midfield leaves all our defenders susceptible at times.
Mangala (6): As above.
Clichy (7.5): He comes out of this season with real credit for me. Works his socks off and I think Pep will love his pressing and intercepting ability.
Demichellis (1): The single worst top division performance I have ever witnessed, totally lost his head and it wouldn't surprise me if he retired this summer. Completely out of his depth at his age.
Kolarov (3): Started the season on fire, looked bang up for it and was defending with purpose. Since then he's given up and let Clichy win the battle of the left backs.
Zabaleta, Kompany unmarked due to injury.
Fernando (6.5): Very poor technically at times but you can't fault his heart and commitment, if he continues playing like he is lately he could force his way into Guardiola's plans.
Fernandinho (8.5): Absolutely immense, love him. Again I can't wait to see what Guardiola will make of him, can see him playing a very similar role to Vidal at Bayern.
Yaya (2): Moments of spectacular brilliance but dominated by lazy, half arsed performances and it's completely killed our ability to press as a team. Poorly utilised by Pellegrini but equally Yaya's effort is very questionable at best.
Delph unmarked due to injury and being played out of position.
Navas (4): Love the guys work rate and commitment but he's an attacking player who doesn't score or assist goals, don't see the point of him.
Sterling (5): Poor season and he's lost his confidence by being asked to play too safe in my opinion but Pep will get the best out of him I have absolutely no doubt.
De Bruyne (8.5): Wow, what a fucking player. Took a few games to settle and doesn't look half the player out wide but played in the middle behind Aguero he looks immense.
Silva and Nasri unmarked due to injury.
Aguero (9): Just sheer class, nothing more to say on the little fella.
Iheanacho (7.5): Brilliant first season and I just hope he kicks on again under Pep. We have to accept that as a kid still he's going to be inconsistent but boy he's got the talent.
Bony (2): Looks half interested and I can't wait for him to fuck off in all honesty. Such a shame because the lad clearly has ability, just don't understand what has gone wrong. He could have been the perfect stand in/different option when Aguero isn't working.
Probably missed a couple out.
I see Silva is getting his usual Bluemoon free pass. That ankle injury must have lasted 2 years!
Ha ha I have been banned 4 less than this when talking about Silva
That's because you do it when he's just been the best player on the pitch. There is a differenceHa ha I have been banned 4 less than this when talking about Silva
Hart (8): Some unbelievable saves and he's become a real leader in the dressing room, just wish his distribution was better.
Willy (5): It would be zero but for the cup final, chuffed for the lad though because the other players clearly like him.
Sagna (6.5): Very solid defensively but sadly doesn't offer us anything going forward.
Otamendi (6): Some outstanding performances, some mind boggling charges out of position but the lack of protection from midfield leaves all our defenders susceptible at times.
Mangala (6): As above.
Clichy (7.5): He comes out of this season with real credit for me. Works his socks off and I think Pep will love his pressing and intercepting ability.
Demichellis (1): The single worst top division performance I have ever witnessed, totally lost his head and it wouldn't surprise me if he retired this summer. Completely out of his depth at his age.
Kolarov (3): Started the season on fire, looked bang up for it and was defending with purpose. Since then he's given up and let Clichy win the battle of the left backs.
Zabaleta, Kompany unmarked due to injury.
Fernando (6.5): Very poor technically at times but you can't fault his heart and commitment, if he continues playing like he is lately he could force his way into Guardiola's plans.
Fernandinho (8.5): Absolutely immense, love him. Again I can't wait to see what Guardiola will make of him, can see him playing a very similar role to Vidal at Bayern.
Yaya (2): Moments of spectacular brilliance but dominated by lazy, half arsed performances and it's completely killed our ability to press as a team. Poorly utilised by Pellegrini but equally Yaya's effort is very questionable at best.
Delph unmarked due to injury and being played out of position.
Navas (4): Love the guys work rate and commitment but he's an attacking player who doesn't score or assist goals, don't see the point of him.
Sterling (5): Poor season and he's lost his confidence by being asked to play too safe in my opinion but Pep will get the best out of him I have absolutely no doubt.
De Bruyne (8.5): Wow, what a fucking player. Took a few games to settle and doesn't look half the player out wide but played in the middle behind Aguero he looks immense.
Silva and Nasri unmarked due to injury.
Aguero (9): Just sheer class, nothing more to say on the little fella.
Iheanacho (7.5): Brilliant first season and I just hope he kicks on again under Pep. We have to accept that as a kid still he's going to be inconsistent but boy he's got the talent.
Bony (2): Looks half interested and I can't wait for him to fuck off in all honesty. Such a shame because the lad clearly has ability, just don't understand what has gone wrong. He could have been the perfect stand in/different option when Aguero isn't working.
Probably missed a couple out.
The first sensible one so far, weird some are marking down using injury as a reason
oakiecokie
Well-Known Member
Strange that everyone else is giving far higher score ratings and one of our few successes this season by a country mile.Yes season ticket holer the reason he gets a 6 is he's a midfielder that can't pass simple as that if he could he would betting 8 or 9
Gundogan's Moustache
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 15 Jan 2014
- Messages
- 4,438
Hart-8
Willy-6
Sagna-7
Zabaleta-5
Kompany-5
Otamendi-6
Mangala-5
Demichellis-3
Kolarov-3
Clichy-6
Fernando-6
Delph-4
Fernandinho-8
Yaya-4
Navas-5
Nasri-NA
De Bruyne-8
Sterling-6
Silva-6
Bony-3
Aguero-8
Iheanacho-7
Pellegrini-5
Willy-6
Sagna-7
Zabaleta-5
Kompany-5
Otamendi-6
Mangala-5
Demichellis-3
Kolarov-3
Clichy-6
Fernando-6
Delph-4
Fernandinho-8
Yaya-4
Navas-5
Nasri-NA
De Bruyne-8
Sterling-6
Silva-6
Bony-3
Aguero-8
Iheanacho-7
Pellegrini-5