Joe Hart (joined Torino on season long loan - Official)

[goalmole]

[QUOTE="karen7, post: 9676178, member: 28652"]You seriously think letting him go 2 months ago would have impacted on us getting a new goalie? we are in a situation of the clubs making now,you are right no-one is bigger than pep but that is not the point i am making[/QUOTE]
Yes. We would have been mugged royally. what world do you live in?

 

[Paul Lake's Left Knee]

You seriously think letting him go 2 months ago would have impacted on us getting a new goalie? we are in a situation of the clubs making now,you are right no-one is bigger than pep but that is not the point i am making

Yes I do, we would have been without a first choice keeper and Bravo would have been nearer £30m than £15m

 

[goalmole]

Yes but where would football be without emotions?
Where would we be if the weather was better? Not all bickering on here I think.
Roll on tomorrow.

I don't think Sheikh Mansour's decision to spend over a £billion to make City one of the worlds premier football clubs was an emotional one.

 

[Tugay One Cup]

I don't think Sheikh Mansour's decision to spend over a £billion to make City one of the worlds premier football clubs was an emotional one.

He'd probably have had a lot to drink though.

 

[ballinio]

Guardiola is paid to make tough decisions & as far as I can see he's making them, nasri....occasional great game is not enough...there's the door.
Ya ya...you've been fantastic for us, thanks but your legs have now gone.
Mangala...got all the attributes to be a great player....bar one ,a footballing brain....been replaced
Joe hart...an average goalkeeper who has not improved his weaknesses over the years,either can't do it or can't be arsed....replaced.
Bravo pep, keep it up.

 

[kaz7]

[QUOTE="karen7, post: 9676178, member: 28652"]You seriously think letting him go 2 months ago would have impacted on us getting a new goalie? we are in a situation of the clubs making now,you are right no-one is bigger than pep but that is not the point i am making

Yes. We would have been mugged royally. what world do you live in?[/QUOTE]
A much nicer one than most of you it seems,pep wanted bravo,we would have got him anyway as he wanted to leave barca,i fail to see how letting joe go before changes that,at least ackowledge the fact we are in a situation now that is distracting everyone and has put joe in a tough place,if he ends up staying it will be a distraction for at least 6 mths more

 

[Paul Lake's Left Knee]

For the last time i am not saying keep him,i am saying it has been handled all wrong and i will always defend the fact he deserved better after 10 yrs,last season he saved us many times,only him,kev and sergio could say they put in the effort

Dinho was player of the season for me, ran for the other 9 outfield players some matches.

I dont care if he was here 10 years or 10 mins, that has nothing to do with the decision to move him on. Its not like he hasnt been handsomely rewarded for his work, I dont feel any sorrow for him, he's a very lucky young millionaire, paid to do what some people pay the privilege of playing. I wish him well in the future, I certainly dont wish ill on him, but the sentiment for a lad from Shrewsbury is a bit OTT for me.

 

[kaz7]

Yes I do, we would have been without a first choice keeper and Bravo would have been nearer £30m than £15m

Joe was told he was 2nd choice so we had willy,some would say he is better (LOL)

 

[Paul Lake's Left Knee]

A much nicer one than most of you it seems,pep wanted bravo,we would have got him anyway as he wanted to leave barca,i fail to see how letting joe go before changes that,at least ackowledge the fact we are in a situation now that is distracting everyone and has put joe in a tough place,if he ends up staying it will be a distraction for at least 6 mths more

A tough place earning £120,000 a week, I wish I was in such a tough position.

If he is a distraction for 6 months, it just adds to Pep's argument to get rid of him.

 

[Paul Lake's Left Knee]

Joe was told he was 2nd choice so we had willy,some would say he is better (LOL)

Is that a fact, how do you know, what he was told and what he thought/felt?

 

[kaz7]

A much nicer one than most of you it seems,pep wanted bravo,we would have got him anyway as he wanted to leave barca,i fail to see how letting joe go before changes that,at least ackowledge the fact we are in a situation now that is distracting everyone and has put joe in a tough place,if he ends up staying it will be a distraction for at least 6 mths more

A tough place earning £120,000 a week, I wish I was in such a tough position.

If he is a distraction for 6 months, it just adds to Pep's argument to get rid of him.[/QUOTE]
He will behave and say nothing,the fact he is in the background will be the distraction and we needn't be in this situation

 

[kaz7]

Is that a fact, how do you know, what he was told and what he thought/felt?

Ric said this morning he was told he would not be no1,search his posts

 

[remember arthur mann]

Get a tenner on him going to Stoke, boy do they need a goalie !!

 

[citizen_maine]

Ric said this morning he was told he would not be no1,search his posts

But was he told Willy would be, or did he just presume?

 

[Paul Lake's Left Knee]

Ric said this morning he was told he would not be no1,search his posts

So Ric knows what he was told and how he felt about it? All respect to our leader but I think that is bollocks, unless Joe is a close friend of his.

 

[Paul Lake's Left Knee]

He will behave and say nothing,the fact he is in the background will be the distraction and we needn't be in this situation

So if he behaves and says nothing, exactly how is he going to be a distraction??

 

[kaz7]

So Ric knows what he was told and how he felt about it? All respect to our leader but I think that is bollocks, unless Joe is a close friend of his.

No-one knows what he felt but Ric doesn't normally post stuff if it's not true
@Ric did i dream you saying joe was told he wouldn't be no 1?

 

[kaz7]

So if he behaves and says nothing, exactly how is he going to be a distraction??

Will he be on the bench or won't he every game,the media will never leave it alone,zooming in on him in the stands or on the bench,pep being asked about him all the time,we can all agree him staying here is not a great thing to happen shirley?

 

[Paul Lake's Left Knee]

No-one knows what he felt but Ric doesn't normally post stuff if it's not true
@Ric did i dream you saying joe was told he wouldn't be no 1?

So nobody knows then, pure guess work from yourself about what has happened, what the reasons are and how Joe has taken it, the manager has said repeatidly its a football decision and he has been open and honest with Joe from the start, that'll do for me, Pep and the club >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Joe Hart.

He's obviously a favourite of yours for you to be so upset at how he has been treated, like I said someone would treat me as shabbily.

 

[Paul Lake's Left Knee]

Will he be on the bench or won't he every game,the media will never leave it alone,zooming in on him in the stands or on the bench,pep being asked about him all the time,we can all agree him staying here is not a great thing to happen shirley?

Not really a great distraction is it? Will he wont he be a sub that will never play.

Him staying isnt the best solution, but its hardly the end of the world if he does. I understand the over reaction from the media about this, cant believe City fans are joining in.