Funny thing is both viewpoints are correct.
No, they aren't. Rodri's critics were pretty clueless from the beginning. They couldn't see his potential and thought he would never be good enough, even after we won 21 games in a row with him starting most of those games! Pep dropped him in the CL final because he lost form (due to being overused by Pep himself), not because he was abysmal over the season. Rodri was mostly excellent in 20/21 bar the last few weeks of the season. Same with Cancelo. The CL starting XI wasn't a verdict on the quality of the players on the bench, just on their form at that moment. In 21/22, Rodri, Cancelo and Laporte played the most minutes and were among our most reliable players.