5 | John Stones - 2023/24

[Alan Harper's Tash]

And who says Walker isn’t captain material? Taking charge and keeping everyone safe.

I mean, the worst that could have happened is that they got pooed on. Pigeons are beyond harmless, but a couple of them weren’t sure about it!

 

[Dialog]

Pigeons are beyond harmless, but a couple of them weren’t sure about it!

If a pigeon could rattle some of them like that, I could just imagine if a live chicken walked in there. The scene would have been glorious!

 

[northmr8]

Big shame he's not had a chance to get going this season, especially after last

 

[Eccles Blue]

Fit enough to keep Pigeoniho in his pocket.

Some people (not you Mr @Alan Harper's Tash) don’t want our pigeon/players saver to stay. They think he should go to Girona I think it was, I’m not going back to look because I might get angry or emotional.
Johnny Boy is going NOWHERE! Leave him be. Pep gave him a big, big hug the other day so he’s happy. Don’t upset me please just before the end of the season. :-)

 

[Tricky_Trev]

What's the reason he isn't playing now available?, seems odd when we have clearly rushed him back early a couple of times this season. Is he still carrying something or has Pep dropped him from his 1st choice line up?

Because we changed our tactics. We do not need a centre back going into midfield. We now play Gvardiol left wing and Foden is now the player moving from their starting position into midfield. With Gvardiol playing higher, Ake has been getting the nod because he’s left footed so gives us the best balance in the back 3 that remains once Gvardiol goes to the wing. With Ake injured, Akanji will now do that role. So it’s purely tactical. This set up has been working and Stones doesn’t really fit in it.

 

[mdj0520]

Because we changed our tactics. We do not need a centre back going into midfield. We now play Gvardiol left wing and Foden is now the player moving from their starting position into midfield. With Gvardiol playing higher, Ake has been getting the nod because he’s left footed so gives us the best balance in the back 3 that remains once Gvardiol goes to the wing. With Ake injured, Akanji will now do that role. So it’s purely tactical. This set up has been working and Stones doesn’t really fit in it.

Good assessment, though I would prefer stones instead of walker as the right back/right sided CB in a back three. Before Saturday I'd have preferred him to Diaz too.

I wonder if part of it is that he's had one his injury hit seasons and the physios and coaching staff know he'll be flogged in the euros and as it's our strongest area in terms of depth we can afford to be patient.

 

[Rammy Blue]

Because we changed our tactics. We do not need a centre back going into midfield. We now play Gvardiol left wing and Foden is now the player moving from their starting position into midfield. With Gvardiol playing higher, Ake has been getting the nod because he’s left footed so gives us the best balance in the back 3 that remains once Gvardiol goes to the wing. With Ake injured, Akanji will now do that role. So it’s purely tactical. This set up has been working and Stones doesn’t really fit in it.

I agree with the not stepping into midfield bit, however imo John is a better centre half than any of the others anyway so would still be playing for me if he’s fully fit.

 

[Txiki Txiki Bang Bang]

I agree with the not stepping into midfield bit, however imo John is a better centre half than any of the others anyway so would still be playing for me if he’s fully fit.

He passes the ball better, apart from that Dias is light years ahead

 

[Rammy Blue]

He passes the ball better, apart from that Dias is light years ahead

Wow. Ok, I’ll leave you with that opinion.

 

[Txiki Txiki Bang Bang]

Wow. Ok, I’ll leave you with that opinion.

Dias defending abilities and athleticism is much better than Stones, sorry I love Stones but if it was down to Dias or Stones, I know who I'm picking. Players have a hard time bullying Dias