i have no real opinion on gundogan, and I think pep is an excellent manager, but to be fair that is an appeal to authority. His decisions can still be constructively criticised. Hes human, he can, has and will make mistakes. Yes he knows a lot more than we do but that doesn't make him immune to getting it wrong, and my personal view is that sometimes he outthinks himself.
I dont wanna argue with you or disrespect you, I know im a guest on this forum and it is for man city fans. Im just saying experts make errors too.