You lot do realise he's 20? Most of the players in our squad weren't good enough to start for City when they were 20.
Ederson, Dias, Reijnders, Stones, Ake, Bernardo, Marmoush, Kovacic, Gonzalez, Rodri, Ait Nouri, Akanji....Go back a few years and KDB, Silva, Mahrez, Walker also fall into that camp.
So why are you expecting more from him than all of them?
Why is it half the forum think the only options are "shit" or "good enough"?
He's starting more than he should be right now because of injuries and squad turnover, but he wouldn't have played 100 games for City at such a young age if he was shit. Giving him a new contract doesn't mean he's contractually got to start every game, I don't see why any City fan wouldn't want to keep him and see where he progresses to in the next 4/5 years *especially* given he's a local lad and lifelong fan. I'm not convinced full back is his position, but I also am not so closed-minded I think a player can't learn "defensive nous" or improve after age 19.