87 | James McAtee - 2024/25

[stan bowles]

Really needs to build on this positive appearance. Been hit and miss no doubt, but could come good at some point. Rooting for the lad.

Pep has to give him some starts now. No point putting him on the bench with no game time for the next few weeks. Showed his quality today.

 

[dhruvblue]

Plays for the badge will play for the badge. Will make mistakes but will give moments too

 

[oldhamblue]

If he doesn't get a couple of starts now then he should leave to get game time elsewhere in January.

 

[eversince 76]

Well played for our second goal. Keep being patient and his time will come. But let’s hope he does not get carried away with this one cameo performance for 20 minutes.

 

[Josh_D]

The reaction from the players may indicate that he does show the goods in training. A few pages back, Pep says he trains well. Well, as some here would say, Pep lies.

Regardless, chuffed for him. Still stand by my previous post here - ‘As they say, pressure makes diamonds. We can’t fully tell if he’s a diamond in the rough or a lacklustre stone to gather dust.’

What he needs to prove that is CONSISTENT game time. Sure, he’ll make mistakes but the senior players do that and have done for a while now. It’s difficult to get into a Pep team as a perceived young player. He’s now 22. Not exactly a kid anymore. Young? Sure but not to the point where he needs hand holding.

I hope this cameo gives him the conviction to prove that he belongs and he can be the very best version of himself on a regular basis.

 

[WesthoughtonJohn]

If he doesn't get a couple of starts now then he should leave to get game time elsewhere in January.

Sadly true - the same applies to O'Reilly - don't really know why given our run of form

 

[don84]

McAtee brought bravoury into our game, making well places risky passess leading to a goal.
While we remove the risk in passing backwards and sideways, we don't win games as James'.
Please Pep, put him in the starting line, we need his energy to build back better confidence.

 

[mdj0520]

If he doesn't get a couple of starts now then he should leave to get game time elsewhere in January.

I'm pretty zen with where we are this season and the current run. Not the worst we've ever seen and we'll come out the other side eventually. What does annoy me is sticking with the same 13 players every single game and not giving the youth a chance. If not now then never. Low and behold a young player comes on (he's not that young anymore) and we look like a completely different team.

I'm going to be fucking furious for the first time in this run if he doesn't start against west ham.

 

[oldius]

Nice to hear such positive post-match comments from Pep about the contribution McAtee made.

 

[Otamendi's Beard]

I used Barker as an example of a stellar youth player not making it in the men’s game, not comparing him as a player.

Still, he’s dropped a shoulder and beaten a man, so he’s now world class. I know how the rhetoric goes!

Nobody has ever claimed he's world class. Simply a player with plenty of potential who's capable of playing in the Premier League.

He stepped into today's game and made a huge difference. Hopefully we'll now see more of him and he can continue to have an impact.

 

[Alan Harper's Tash]

Nobody has ever claimed he's world class. Simply a player with plenty of potential who's capable of playing in the Premier League.

He stepped into today's game and made a huge difference. Hopefully we'll now see more of him and he can continue to have an impact.

Sigh. Okay mate. Let’s leave it there. We obviously have difficulty understanding each others syntax.

 

[.db.]

Buzzing for the lad. Loves City, loves playing for City, doesn’t want to leave City… onwards and upwards for him here.

Up the Blues!

 

[clarion]

Nice to hear such positive post-match comments from Pep about the contribution McAtee made.

Yeah. That usually means next 5 games with 0 minutes on the pitch.
Let’s hope not this time.

 

[Blue and true]

Earned a start against West Ham. Did more in five minutes than some of the others did in ninety.

 

[Dax777]

Aight, aight!!!! Hands up! I was one of the big-time doubting cunts

So happy for him :)

 

[bluegaz13]

I used Barker as an example of a stellar youth player not making it in the men’s game, not comparing him as a player.

Still, he’s dropped a shoulder and beaten a man, so he’s now world class. I know how the rhetoric goes!

You sound disappointed that he produced a moment of class.

Did all that could be asked of him when he came on.

The only way we will know if he has that little bit of extra ability to make it as a premiership player is by him being given some playing time.

Don’t judge him on his Sheffield United experience…..playing in a poor team has affected some of our big player’s performances this season.

 

[Alan Harper's Tash]

You sound disappointed that he produced a moment of class.

Well I’m not, so you can cross that off your list.

 

[oldhamblue]

Can we not all he happy that we've won a game instead of picking fights with other posters FFS

 

[freshie]

 

[117 M34]

I've been critical of him but in reality, he did more in half an hour today than foden has done all season.
Got to start against West ham and Salford.