9 | Erling Haaland - 2023/24

[RayCTID]

Van Djik's approach to that move was exemplary. That's why he's still one of the best defenders in the game. That said, I honestly think that 22/23 Haaland would have beaten Van Djik and scored in exactly the same situation. He's falling a long way short of his performances last season imo.

Missed a good chunk of the season through injury and is still trying to get back up to full speed and despite that 29 goals from 33 appearances is not to be sniffed at.

 

[Lavinda Past]

Missed a good chunk of the season through injury and is still trying to get back up to full speed and despite that 29 goals from 33 appearances is not to be sniffed at.

I certainly won't disagree with you on that Ray!

 

[city2]

He’s still learning his trade, control of the ball needs to be worked on though esp first touch.

 

[Keeper!]

Haaland's workrate in midfield is almost non-existent week in, week out. He's not a particularly good footballer, just a red hot striker.
When he's not scoring, he's very ineffective.
Kane is at the very least a good all-round footballer.

To be fair Harry Kane as 23 was a striker getting farmed out to Championship clubs, with serious question marks if he could make it at the top level.

He developed into that superb footballer and goalscorer, it took time.

Haaland is young and has a hell of a lot to learn, he was shocking at Anfield but I do wonder how fit he really is since that injury, which was also probably a lot more serious than has been stated.

 

[jaiguruKun]

I thought he played well personally. Took up some good positions, held it up well and laid it off when he needed to. The issues we had re ball retention were nothing to do with him. His workmate is not as high as someone like Nunez but if it was he wouldn't score as many goals.

 

[Keeper!]

I agree to disagree. One striker isn't better than the other and if anything Haaland has achieved a lot more in his short career despite his percieved deficiencies.We don't need extra creativity or our striker to run around like a lunatic we just lack the finish. Haaland's golden chance was well defended by van Dijk.

"our striker to run around like a lunatic"

Very true but we need all our front line pressing hard on the defenders, something we used to be the very best at but no longer.

 

[eastmanc]

I was gutted we didnt get Kane. All round offers so much more.. better passer better finishes..all round 2 the CF but i still love Haaland's attitude

I agree about Harry Kane as a footballer, his all round game is better than Earliing's. Haaland cost us 51 million and is 23 Kane would have cost us over double that and is 31. Haaland every time for me.

 

[Kamaro011]

I agree about Harry Kane as a footballer, his all round game is better than Earliing's. Haaland cost us 51 million and is 23 Kane would have cost us over double that and is 31. Haaland every time for me.

I hope Haaland improves his all around game like Kane sooner.

 

[Lovebitesandeveryfing]

I agree about Harry Kane as a footballer, his all round game is better than Earliing's. Haaland cost us 51 million and is 23 Kane would have cost us over double that and is 31. Haaland every time for me.

Every footballer who comes to City says the same thing: they look, they learn. They become better footballers. (Well, maybe not Kalvin. I think he was just a bit terrified when he saw the level that's taken for granted, in training, on match days).
That's not just Pep. It's the general coaching staff. It's the medical set-up. It's the training facilities. It's the team-mates, above all.
Erling looked simply invisible on Sunday. I think he was my greatest disappointment. But he will look, he will learn, and he will get better. That's virtually a certainty (did pretty well last year, to be fair).

 

[Tolmie scores]

I agree about Harry Kane as a footballer, his all round game is better than Earliing's. Haaland cost us 51 million and is 23 Kane would have cost us over double that and is 31. Haaland every time for me.

I have weighed that up and i do think we are a couple of seasons stop gap for Erling IF he keeps smashing records. This is where his 5 v Luton reserves helps (Tim Kruhl in nets bloody 'ell) if they don't scrutinise who he scored against too much we could see a £150m sale to Real Madrid which is great business. BUT i would rather have had Kane for 3 years - cost us more but i think we would be a better team to watch and would likely win more. His control, hold up play etc. would have been much needed v Dippers. He can play with his back to goal, lead the line, drop deep and play balls akin to KDB, a genuinely gifted lad AND no one can fault his attitude and professionalism. Pep's dream player in terms of character, a proper leader by example. Ahh well lol

 

[Lavinda Past]

To be fair Harry Kane as 23 was a striker getting farmed out to Championship clubs, with serious question marks if he could make it at the top level.

He developed into that superb footballer and goalscorer, it took time.

Haaland is young and has a hell of a lot to learn, he was shocking at Anfield but I do wonder how fit he really is since that injury, which was also probably a lot more serious than has been stated.

I appreciate that. What I'm saying is that I believe it would have been better for the balance of the team if we had signed the 29 year old finished article rather than the raw talent.

Whether it's through injury or transfer, I don't think we'll see peak Haaland at City.

There are very good football reasons why Pep wanted Kane. There were very different commercial reasons behind the club signing Haaland and publicly pursuing Messi and Ronaldo.

 

[Otamendi's Beard]

I thought he played well personally. Took up some good positions, held it up well and laid it off when he needed to. The issues we had re ball retention were nothing to do with him. His workmate is not as high as someone like Nunez but if it was he wouldn't score as many goals.

I agree. He did some great balls out to the left to lay people in perfectly.

I don't think he received one good cross and KDB and Alvarez were both guilty of poor deliveries when in good positions.

 

[vmsuhail]

I agree. He did some great balls out to the left to lay people in perfectly.

I don't think he received one good cross and KDB and Alvarez were both guilty of poor deliveries when in good positions.

.. and Walker who found himself twice in good crossing positions and put it in no man's land.

 

[Mancini’s Pastilles]

People are regretting signing haaland? Have I lost my mind? Or what the fuck is going on. Regretting signing haaland ? Now ,ive come out with some mad takes on this forum in my time. But this takes the buiscuit

 

[BlueTG]

If you want a striker like Haaland to impact a team like Liverpool, you need to feed him the ball. We didn’t.

No point asking him to charge around like a mad man possessed, it’s not his game.

And as to those saying we would have won more with Kane, did I imagine that treble? Or Kane’s trophyless season so far?

 

[bluedreamer]

If you want a striker like Haaland to impact a team like Liverpool, you need to feed him the ball. We didn’t.

No point asking him to charge around like a mad man possessed, it’s not his game.

And as to those saying we would have won more with Kane, did I imagine that treble? Or Kane’s trophyless season so far?

We have KDB, Silva, Foden and Rodri, 4 of the best midfield players in the Prem. If they can’t find Haaland you have to question his ability to find space and make himself available.
He always runs away from the ball to the far post. We prefer to play to feet not hoof in speculative crosses .

 

[Belgian Flash]

If you want a striker like Haaland to impact a team like Liverpool, you need to feed him the ball. We didn’t.

No point asking him to charge around like a mad man possessed, it’s not his game.

Its okay if playing with the ball is not your game, or if playing off the ball (which includes heavy pressing) is also not your game. But both - I don't think it can be said its acceptable because its not your game. If a player doesn't offer anything to the buildup or hounds the opposition, whenever he doesn't score he will be a big liability.

 

[Gordyola]

I think he is carrying a shoulder injury watch his demeanour and he is pressing anywhere near as much as he was previously, on the latest Inside City he is seen in the treatment room and it appears they are working on his left arm Might be just putting 2 and 2 together and getting 10?

 

[MCFC Wirral]

I’d have chosen Haaland over Kane because of his age. He was also the more likely signing given Spurs not selling to a domestic rival.

A fully fit Haaland starts every match for me. His goals will win things.

 

[Phil1]

People are regretting signing haaland? Have I lost my mind? Or what the fuck is going on. Regretting signing haaland ? Now ,ive come out with some mad takes on this forum in my time. But this takes the buiscuit

This forum is worse than Rawk or Redcafe. Some god awful posters on here these days.